Critique of the UK Carbon Plan: The Future of Emissions and Costs

The UK's carbon capture, use and storage plan is under fire for rising costs and unrealistic economic assumptions, according to a Carbon Tracker report published on March 13.
Stratégie Carbone Britannique: Analyse Critique des Coûts et des Applications du CCUS

Partagez:

London think tank Carbon Tracker points out that the UK’s Carbon Capture, Utilization and Storage (CCUS) plan faces major challenges. According to the report published on March 13, the costs of deploying this strategy have more than doubled since 2020. This significant increase, attributed in part to inflation, calls into question the economic viability of the program.

Cost analysis

The UK government had initially set ambitious targets, aiming to capture between 20 and 30 million tonnes of CO2 per year. In addition, the UK has earmarked a further £22 million for renewable energies. However, Carbon Tracker believes that actual demand for this technology may be lower than initially forecast. Rising costs, combined with lower potential demand, raise concerns about the program’s profitability. It seems that, despite the £1 billion earmarked for industry in the UK to achieve carbon neutrality, there’s still a long way to go.
The report also highlights the technical challenges associated with certain applications of CCUS technology. For example, in the steel sector, Carbon Tracker recommends abandoning carbon capture plans, arguing that producers are already turning to alternative technologies such as electric arc furnaces. This transition to more sustainable production methods could reduce the need for CCUS in certain industrial sectors.

Perspectives and reactions

In the face of this criticism, the British government is defending its CCUS program as an essential component of its climate strategy. In particular, it underlines the crucial role of carbon capture in reducing greenhouse gas emissions, in line with carbon neutrality objectives.
However, Carbon Tracker’s comments underline the need for the government to review its strategy and focus its resources on higher value-added applications, such as cement and hydrogen. This strategic reorientation would optimize the effectiveness of investments in emissions reduction, while ensuring long-term economic competitiveness.
In response to the criticism, a spokesperson for the UK Department for Energy Security and Carbon Neutrality stressed the importance of CCUS in ensuring the country’s energy security. He also stressed the essential role of this technology in the transformation of sectors such as steel, cement and chemicals.

Criticism of CCUS’s UK plan highlights the challenges facing the transition to a low-carbon economy. As the UK strives to reduce its emissions, it is imperative to strike a balance between climate imperatives and economic realities. Revising and adapting CCUS strategies is therefore essential.

Stockholm Exergi begins construction of a CO₂ capture facility in Stockholm, integrated with the expansion of Northern Lights in Norway, reaching a total storage capacity of 5 million tonnes per year by 2028.
Global emissions coverage by carbon pricing systems reaches 28%, driven by expanding compliance markets, where demand nearly tripled within one year, according to a World Bank report.
Vietnam initiates a pilot carbon market targeting steel, cement, and thermal energy industries to prepare for nationwide regulation starting in 2029.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) proposes granting Texas direct authority to issue carbon dioxide injection permits, potentially accelerating the commercial expansion of geological CO₂ storage projects.
Höegh Evi and Aker BP received Approval in Principle from DNV for a maritime carrier designed to transport liquefied CO₂ to offshore storage sites in Norway.
Norne and the Port of Aalborg begin construction of a 15 mn tonne per year CO2 terminal, supported by an EU grant.
The Lagos State government has launched a programme to deploy 80 million improved cookstoves, generating up to 1.2 billion tonnes of tradable carbon credits.
The US Department of Energy has cancelled 24 projects funded under the Biden administration, citing their lack of profitability and alignment with national energy priorities.
In the United States, the carbon black market faces unprecedented fluctuations in the first half of 2025, driven by declining industrial demand and persistent raw material volatility, casting doubts over the sector's future stability.
European and UK carbon markets paused this week as participants await clarity on future integration of both emissions trading systems.
A consortium led by European Energy has secured prequalification for a Danish carbon capture and storage project in Næstved, aiming to remove 150,000 tons of CO₂ per year under a national subsidy programme.
The joint project by Copenhagen Infrastructure Partners and Vestforbrænding is among ten initiatives selected by the Danish Energy Agency for public carbon capture and storage funding.
Canadian broker One Exchange partners with Stephen Avenue Marketing to create OX CO₂, a carbon trading platform combining digital technology and human expertise.
Russia has filed a complaint with the World Trade Organization (WTO) challenging the European Union's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), deeming it discriminatory and protectionist towards its strategic commodity exports.
BP recommends extending the UK emissions trading system through 2042 and calls for alignment with the European market while supporting the inclusion of carbon removals in the scheme.
Aker takes over Aker Carbon Capture’s stake in SLB Capturi for NOK635mn, ahead of a NOK1.7bn distribution and company dissolution.
The partnership aims to develop a full logistics chain for CO2 capture, transport, liquefaction and storage, focused on Calcinor’s industrial operations.
In response to increasingly stringent environmental regulations, the world's leading oil companies are significantly boosting their investments in carbon capture and storage (CCS) technologies, reshaping their industrial and financial strategies.
HYCO1 and Malaysia LNG Sdn. Bhd. have signed a memorandum of understanding for a carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and utilization project in Bintulu, Malaysia, aiming to transform 1 million tons of CO2 per year into low-emission syngas.
Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage (CCU) technologies are gaining traction in hard-to-decarbonize industrial sectors, offering innovative and economically viable solutions. The Oxford Institute for Energy Studies report explores these new pathways.