Countries accused of overstating carbon sinks to slow energy transition

Countries such as Brazil and Australia are criticised for overstating the CO2 absorption capacity of their forests, a practice that undermines their commitment to reducing greenhouse gas emissions, according to a report by Climate Analytics.

Share:

Major powers, including Brazil and Australia, are accused of manipulating figures related to the CO2 absorption capacity of their forests in order to slow their transition away from fossil fuels while claiming to meet their climate commitments. This analysis comes from a report by the institute Climate Analytics, published on April 24, 2025, which highlights the weakness of the rules governing the accounting of carbon sinks. These loopholes provide the opportunity to inflate greenhouse gas emissions reduction figures.

Carbon sinks, which include soils, forests, and wetlands, are supposed to absorb a portion of CO2 emitted by human activities. However, these natural areas are difficult to assess accurately, and scientists fear that they absorb less due to the effects of climate change, such as more frequent wildfires. These uncertainties have not prevented some countries from adopting optimistic assumptions that artificially improve their national carbon balances.

This approach allows some countries to present a more favourable balance while delaying their energy transition, a strategy that could be reinforced during the upcoming climate conference, COP30, scheduled for November 2025 in Brazil. The report from Climate Analytics warns that these practices obscure the scale and speed of the fossil fuel emission reductions needed for each country to do its part under the Paris Agreement.

Examples of contested practices

Since 2018, Australia has repeatedly reassessed the impact of its forests on its carbon balance. According to the latest estimates, it claims to have reduced its net CO2 emissions by 28% between 2005 and 2024, despite its gross emissions decreasing by only 2%. This revision makes Australia a striking example of a country that, while increasing its absorption assumptions, minimises the real impact of its energy policy.

Meanwhile, Brazil has announced that it will reduce its carbon pollution by 59% to 67% by 2035 compared to 2005, but without specifying the exact role of its forests in this reduction. According to the Climate Analytics institute, this reflects a manipulation of figures that allows the country to mask the slow pace of its necessary energy transition.

Lack of international rules

The report denounces the absence of strict rules to regulate assumptions about the performance of carbon sinks. The 2015 Paris Agreement allows each country to formulate its own estimates, a flexibility that, according to Claudio Forner, co-author of the study, encourages some states to “play with the system.” He points out that without strict rules, these countries continue to artificially inflate their emission reductions, hindering ambitious climate action.

According to Climate Analytics experts, the uncertainty around the effectiveness of carbon sinks could account for up to three billion tonnes of CO2, a volume equivalent to the annual emissions of the European Union.

Rapid growth in solar and wind capacities will lead to a significant rise in electricity curtailment in Brazil, as existing transmission infrastructure remains inadequate to handle this massive influx of energy, according to a recent study by consulting firm Wood Mackenzie.
In April 2025, fossil fuels represented 49.5% of South Korea's electricity mix, dropping below the symbolic threshold of 50% for the first time, primarily due to a historic decline in coal-generated electricity production.
The US Senate Finance Committee modifies the '45Z' tax credit to standardize the tax treatment of renewable fuels, thereby encouraging advanced biofuel production starting October 2025.
While advanced economies maintain global energy leadership, China and the United States have significantly progressed in the security and sustainability of their energy systems, according to the World Economic Forum's annual report.
On the sidelines of the US–Africa summit in Luanda, Algiers and Luanda consolidate their energy collaboration to better exploit their oil, gas, and mining potential, targeting a common strategy in regional and international markets.
The UK's Climate Change Committee is urging the government to quickly reduce electricity costs to facilitate the adoption of heat pumps and electric vehicles, judged too slow to achieve the set climate targets.
The European Commission will extend until the end of 2030 an expanded state-aid framework, allowing capitals to fund low-carbon technologies and nuclear power to preserve competitiveness against China and the United States.
Japan's grid operator forecasts an energy shortfall of up to 89 GW by 2050 due to rising demand from semiconductor manufacturing, electric vehicles, and artificial intelligence technologies.
Energy-intensive European industries will be eligible for temporary state aid to mitigate high electricity prices, according to a new regulatory framework proposed by the European Commission under the "Clean Industrial Deal."
Mauritius seeks international investors to swiftly build a floating power plant of around 100 MW, aiming to secure the national energy supply by January 2026 and address current production shortfalls.
Madrid announces immediate energy storage measures while Lisbon secures its electrical grid, responding to the historic outage that affected the entire Iberian Peninsula in late April.
Indonesia has unveiled its new national energy plan, projecting an increase of 69.5 GW in electricity capacity over ten years, largely funded by independent producers, to address rapidly rising domestic demand.
French Minister Agnès Pannier-Runacher condemns the parliamentary moratorium on new renewable energy installations, warning of the potential loss of 150,000 industrial jobs and increased energy dependence on foreign countries.
The European battery regulation, fully effective from August 18, significantly alters industrial requirements related to electric cars and bicycles, imposing strict rules on recycling, supply chains, and transparency for companies.
The European Parliament calls on the Commission to strengthen energy infrastructure and accelerate the implementation of the Clean Industrial Deal to enhance the continent's energy flexibility and security amid increased market volatility.
The European Commission unveils an ambitious plan to modernize electricity grids and introduces the Clean Industrial Deal, mobilizing hundreds of billions of euros to strengthen the continent's industrial and energy autonomy.
In the United States, regulated electric grid operators hold a decisive advantage in connecting new data centres to the grid, now representing 134 GW of projects, according to a Wood Mackenzie report published on June 19.
The French National Assembly approves a specific target of 200 TWh renewable electricity production by 2030 within a legislative text extensively debated about the future national energy mix.
In 2024, US CO₂ emissions remain stable at 5.1bn tonnes, as the Trump administration prepares hydrocarbon-friendly energy policies, raising questions about the future evolution of the American market.
The early publication of France's energy decree triggers strong parliamentary reactions, as the government aims to rapidly secure investments in nuclear and other energy sectors.