Colombian Carbon Market Under Pressure: Excess Credits and Waning Confidence

Colombia is experiencing a significant drop in voluntary carbon credit prices due to a major oversupply, destabilizing the financial balance of associated communities and projects.

Share:

The Colombian carbon market is facing a sharp price decline caused by an unprecedented accumulation of credits, primarily from projects focused on Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation (REDD+). According to the industry association Asocarbono, the country has a surplus exceeding 60 million carbon credits, creating a market scenario where buyers now dictate financial terms. This surplus of unsold credits particularly affects economic stakeholders, as well as rural communities heavily dependent on these revenues for their development.

Immediate Economic Impact on Local Communities
Current market challenges directly affect the finances of rural communities involved in carbon projects. Certain initiatives, involving several dozen communities and spanning hundreds of thousands of hectares, currently have millions of unsold credits in their inventories. The absence of commercial outlets endangers the funding of local projects, threatening their short-term economic viability. Some communities might even consider reverting to alternative economic activities—potentially harmful ones such as illicit coca cultivation or deforestation—to generate immediate income.

Fiscal Reform and Regulatory Tensions
The recent fiscal reform adopted by the Colombian government now limits the use of domestic carbon credits to offset tax obligations of local companies to 50%, whereas previously companies could fully offset their carbon taxes using these credits. This regulatory shift has directly reduced demand for carbon credits, exacerbating the price decline. Additionally, delays in implementing an official Emissions Trading System (ETS) have created regulatory uncertainty and hampered investments in the sector.

Governance Issues and Community Consent
Several REDD+ projects have faced criticism for not adhering to the principle of Free, Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC) with affected indigenous communities. Certain communities have reported discovering the existence of projects belatedly or not fully understanding the terms under which credits linked to their territories were sold. This situation raises concerns about governance and transparency within carbon offset projects, diminishing overall trust in these mechanisms.

Concerns Regarding Transparency of the Voluntary Market
Recent international reports have flagged potential risks concerning financial transparency and the integrity of certain carbon projects in Colombia, particularly in the Amazon region. These findings have led sector stakeholders to demand stricter regulations and improved traceability of financial flows. Investor confidence is now closely tied to Colombia’s capacity to address these concerns effectively.

Emergence of New Forms of Ecological Valuation
Faced with these uncertainties, new financial mechanisms are emerging, notably biodiversity credits. These allow financial valuation of specific environmental services independent from traditional carbon credits. Several Colombian stakeholders are currently developing such mechanisms to diversify potential revenue streams for rural communities and thereby reduce their reliance on the traditional carbon market.

These developments raise new questions for economic and financial actors involved in Colombia. Market stabilization now appears dependent on the country’s ability to establish a clear and transparent regulatory framework that meets both economic needs and international investor expectations.

TotalEnergies seals partnership with NativState to develop thirteen forestry management projects across 100,000 hectares, providing an economic alternative to intensive timber harvesting for hundreds of private landowners.
Drax’s generation site recorded a 16% rise in its emissions, consolidating its position as the UK’s main emitter, according to analysis published by think tank Ember.
Graphano Energy announces an initial mineral resource estimate for its Lac Saguay graphite properties in Québec, highlighting immediate development potential near major transport routes, supported by independent analyses.
Carbon2Nature, a subsidiary of Iberdrola, partners with law firm Uría Menéndez on a 90-hectare reforestation project in Sierra de Francia, targeting carbon footprint compensation for the legal sector.
North Sea Farmers has carried out the very first commercial-scale seaweed harvest in an offshore wind farm, supported by funding from the Amazon Right Now climate fund.
The UK's National Wealth Fund participates in a GBP 59.6 million funding round to finance a CO₂ capture pipeline for the cement and lime industry, targeting a final investment decision by 2028.
The Bayou Bend project, led by Chevron, Equinor, and TotalEnergies, aims to become a major hub for industrial carbon dioxide storage on the US Gulf Coast, with initial phases already completed.
US-based Chloris Geospatial has raised $8.5M from international investors to expand its satellite-based forest monitoring capabilities and strengthen its commercial position in Europe, addressing growing demand in the carbon market.
The federal government is funding three carbon capture, utilisation and storage initiatives in Alberta, strengthening national energy competitiveness and preparing infrastructure aligned with long-term emission-reduction goals.
Donald Trump approves a substantial increase in US tax credits aimed at carbon capture and utilization in oil projects, significantly reshaping economic outlooks for the energy sector and drawing attention from specialized investors.
The European Union unveils a plan aimed at protecting its exporting industries from rising carbon policy costs, using revenue generated from its border adjustment mechanism.
France and Norway sign an agreement facilitating the international transport of CO₂ to offshore geological storage facilities, notably through the Northern Lights project and the CO₂ Highway Europe infrastructure.
Frontier Infrastructure Holdings has signed an offtake agreement with manager Wild Assets for up to 120 000 tonnes of BECCS credits, underscoring the voluntary market’s growing appetite for traceable, high-permanence carbon removals.
Global carbon capture and offset credit markets could exceed $1.35 trillion by 2050, driven by private investment, technological advances, and regulatory developments, according to analysis published by Wood Mackenzie.
The Australian carbon credit market is experiencing temporary price stabilization, while the emergence of new alternative financial instruments gradually attracts corporate attention, subtly altering the commercial and financial dynamics of the sector.
Norway has launched a major industrial project aimed at capturing, maritime transport, and geological storage of CO₂, mobilizing key energy players and significant public subsidies to ensure economic viability.
A €21mn European grant, managed by EIB Global, will fund Egyptian projects aimed at cutting industrial emissions and boosting recycling, while a related €135mn loan is expected to raise additional climate investments.
Stockholm Exergi begins construction of a CO₂ capture facility in Stockholm, integrated with the expansion of Northern Lights in Norway, reaching a total storage capacity of 5 million tonnes per year by 2028.
Global emissions coverage by carbon pricing systems reaches 28%, driven by expanding compliance markets, where demand nearly tripled within one year, according to a World Bank report.
Vietnam initiates a pilot carbon market targeting steel, cement, and thermal energy industries to prepare for nationwide regulation starting in 2029.