SUBSCRIBE
PROFILE

Coal Lawsuit: BlackRock Warns on U.S. Energy Independence

Financial giant BlackRock highlights economic and strategic risks linked to an antitrust procedure backed by Washington, targeting major asset managers accused of conspiring to reduce coal production in the United States.

Share:

Gain full professional access to energynews.pro from 4.90€/month.
Designed for decision-makers, with no long-term commitment.

Over 30,000 articles published since 2021.
150 new market analyses every week to decode global energy trends.

Monthly Digital PRO PASS

Immediate Access
4.90€/month*

No commitment – cancel anytime, activation in 2 minutes.

START NOW — 4.90€/month

*Special launch offer: 1st month at the indicated price, then 14.90 €/month, no long-term commitment.

Annual Digital PRO Pass

Full Annual Access
99€/year*

To access all of energynews.pro without any limits

SUBSCRIBE — 99€/year

*Introductory annual price for year one, automatically renewed at 149.00 €/year from the second year.

Sign up for free to unlock this article

The legal controversy involving BlackRock, Vanguard, and State Street Global Advisors (SSGA) raises new questions about the stability of U.S. energy markets. These three major asset managers are accused by thirteen U.S. states, led by Texas, of using their cross-shareholdings in coal companies to influence production, in a case officially backed by the Department of Justice (DOJ) and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC).

Accusations against Asset Managers

At the heart of the lawsuit, filed in late 2024, lies the accusation of anticompetitive conspiracy under the guise of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) objectives. According to the plaintiffs, these companies allegedly leveraged their influence within the coal sector to artificially reduce production, violating Section 1 of the Sherman Act and Section 7 of the Clayton Act—two fundamental U.S. antitrust laws.

This legal action is reinforced by a joint statement from the DOJ and FTC, officially supporting the states’ case. Federal agencies emphasize that coordination, even if driven by ESG considerations, remains illegal if it restricts competition in energy markets, especially coal.

Responses from Accused Companies

In response to these accusations, BlackRock described the action as “baseless,” emphasizing that the lawsuit could paradoxically weaken industry companies by restricting their access to capital. According to BlackRock, such a scenario could lead to higher energy prices in the U.S. market, directly threatening the national strategy aimed at ensuring U.S. energy independence.

SSGA also rejects the allegations, expressing confidence in the judicial process to come, while Vanguard expresses reservations regarding the legal interpretation of the lawsuit, reaffirming compliance with existing antitrust laws. The company highlights that it has remained within legal boundaries, particularly regarding passive investment and shareholder engagement.

Potential Economic Consequences

The outcome of this case could have significant repercussions for the entire U.S. coal industry, which remains crucial for electricity generation in several regions of the United States. A ruling against the asset management firms might force these companies to gradually withdraw from the sector, directly affecting financing capabilities and strategic development of American coal companies.

Concurrently, the official stance adopted by federal agencies in this matter could have lasting effects on ESG investment regulation, particularly in industries sensitive to regulatory pressures and carbon emission reduction targets.

The case, soon to be examined in federal courts, may also set an important legal precedent by clearly defining the limits of shareholder engagement in managing fossil fuel-related energy assets.

  • Popular on energynews.pro
OMV fires executive accused of links to Russian espionage in Vienna
EMBER: Mexico could cover 90% of its electricity demand with solar
Iberdrola plans €58 billion investment to boost growth by 2028
Cedar LNG becomes the world’s first majority Indigenous-owned LNG terminal
La Caisse invests $724 mn to acquire Australia’s Edify Energy
Russia shifts coal exports toward Asia, expert says
Facing Western restrictions, Russia plans to increase coal deliveries to China, India and Turkey, according to a recent presentation on the sector’s outlook.
Shanghai Electric strengthens energy investments in Pakistan with $3bn project
The visit of the Pakistani president to Shanghai Electric marks a new strategic phase in China-Pakistan energy cooperation, centred on the Thar mining and power project and local skills development.
Russia and Indonesia overtake Australia in South Korea’s thermal coal supply
Port congestion in Australia has boosted Russian and Indonesian coal exports to South Korea, with both now dominating the market due to lower prices and reliable delivery schedules.
JSW restarts coal output with two new longwalls in September
Polish state-owned producer JSW confirms its 13.4 million tonnes production target for 2025 thanks to new equipment coming online, despite recent disruptions at multiple sites.
Australian port congestion reshapes coal flows to South Korea
Russia and Indonesia overtook Australia as South Korea's top thermal coal suppliers in August, driven by lower prices and more reliable logistics amid persistent Australian shipment delays.
Uniper demolishes 116-metre cooling tower at Scholven site
Uniper has demolished cooling tower F at its Scholven power plant, marking a new stage in the dismantling of the Gelsenkirchen coal site, where the energy company plans to build a hydrogen-ready gas-fired plant.
Australian coal exposes global steelmakers to hidden climate risk
Underreported methane emissions from Australian mines could increase steelmakers’ carbon footprint by up to 15%, according to new analysis highlighting major gaps in global supply chains.
Russia targets 30 million tons of coal transported via Pacific Railway by 2026
The new Russian railway line linking the Elga mine to the Sea of Okhotsk port will reach full capacity in 2026, after an operational testing phase scheduled for 2025.
Romania negotiates with Brussels to extend coal plants until 2031
The Romanian government is asking the European Union for a five-year delay on the closure of 2.6 gigawatts of coal capacity, citing delays in bringing gas and solar alternatives online.
Colombia: Petro blocks coal to Israel in a political showdown
President Gustavo Petro bans all coal exports to Israel, a decision with minor energy effects but strong diplomatic weight, illustrating his anti-Americanism and attempts to reshape Colombia’s domestic politics.
India diversifies coking coal purchases, Australia retreats
India’s coking coal imports are rising and increasingly split between the United States and Russia, while Australian producers redirect volumes to China; 2025 results confirm a shift in trade flows.
China: 25 GW of coal approved in H1 2025, commissioning surges
China approved 25 GW in H1 2025 and commissioned 21 GW; the annual total could exceed 80 GW. Proposals reached 75 GW and coal’s share fell to 51% in June, amid declining imports.
Vitol and Breakwall finance $150M to support a metallurgical coal mine
Valor Mining Credit Partners completes its first major financing with a secured loan to strengthen the operational capacity of a U.S. mining site.
The U.S. Department of Energy Extends Operations of a Coal Plant in the Midwest
Amid tensions on the Midwest power grid, Washington orders the continued operation of the J.H. Campbell plant to secure electricity supply over the coming months.
Peabody cancels its $3.78 billion bid for Anglo’s coal mines
Peabody Energy abandons the acquisition of Anglo American’s Australian coal assets, triggering an arbitration process following the failure of a post-incident agreement at the Moranbah North mine.
Core Natural Resources reports USD220.2mn in cash flow and adjusts its financial policy
Core Natural Resources announces USD220.2mn in operating cash flow for the second quarter of 2025, while revising its capital return strategy and increasing post-merger synergies.
Global demand could extend coal’s role beyond 2030
A report by Wood Mackenzie reveals that geopolitical pressures and rising global electricity demand could keep coal-fired generation elevated well beyond current forecasts.
Ramaco opens first US rare earth mine in 70 years
Ramaco Resources officially opens in the United States the first mine dedicated to rare earths in seven decades, also inaugurating Wyoming's first new coal mining operation in over half a century during a ceremony attended by senior political officials.
Turkey’s Eren Energi seeks 375,000 tonnes of thermal coal before December
Turkish power producer Eren Energi Elektrik Uretim has launched a tender to buy 375,000 tonnes of thermal coal to be delivered in five shipments starting from August 2025, according to a document seen by Platts on June 27.
Ireland exits coal permanently with closure of Moneypoint power plant
Ireland ends four decades of coal-based electricity production by converting its Moneypoint power plant to heavy fuel oil, now exclusively reserved for the balancing market until 2029.

Log in to read this article

You'll also have access to a selection of our best content.