Chevron and Exxon Mobil: Conflict of Control in Guyana

Chevron and Exxon Mobil clash in arbitration over control of the Hess oil asset in Guyana, one of the world's largest oil discoveries.

Share:

Conflit de contrôle Exxon Chevron

The dispute between Chevron and Exxon Mobil revolves around Chevron’s $53 billion acquisition of Hess Corporation, and more specifically the takeover of Hess’s oil assets in Guyana. Exxon Mobil, which owns 45% of the consortium operating the offshore field in Guyana, contested the acquisition, arguing that the change of control triggers its pre-emptive right over Hess’s 30% stake in the project.
In 2008, Exxon drew up the Joint Operation Agreement (JOA) with its partners, including Hess and CNOOC, to govern operations on the Stabroek oil block in Guyana. This agreement stipulates that any change of control, direct or indirect, could trigger pre-emption rights. Chevron and Hess argue that this acquisition does not involve a change of control under the JOA definition.

Positions of the parties

Exxon Mobil argues that the right of first refusal is activated by any change of control, direct or indirect, which Chevron allegedly tried to circumvent. Chevron and Hess, for their part, argue that the structure of the acquisition leaves Hess intact as a unit within Chevron, not constituting a change of control under the terms of the contract.
James English, an oil M&A expert at Clark Hill Law, explains that the debate centers on the interpretation of the contract: “A literal approach would be very much in Chevron’s favor, while an analysis based on intent could find in Exxon’s favor.” If the arbitration panel opts for an intent analysis, this could result in protracted proceedings involving discovery, interrogatories and independent assessments, thereby delaying resolution.

Legal implications

The arbitration panel must determine whether the language of the contract is clear or whether the intention behind the words needs to be examined. A literal interpretation would favor Chevron, while an analysis based on intent could find in Exxon’s favor. Resolving this conflict may require in-depth discoveries and independent assessments, delaying a resolution until next year.
Chevron and Hess claim that the acquisition is structured to maintain Hess as a separate entity, which they argue does not constitute a change of control. However, Exxon argues that the structure of the acquisition is an attempt to circumvent the pre-emption rights stipulated in the JOA.

Economic stakes

Guyana is a key player, with projected production of 1.9 million barrels of oil equivalent per day within a decade, far outstripping countries like Venezuela. Most of the value of Chevron’s acquisition of Hess rests on these Guyanese assets, representing 60-80% of the total offer, according to experts.
The outcome of this arbitration could have major repercussions on the future strategies of the oil giants in terms of acquisitions and rights of first refusal in international partnerships. In the event of victory, Exxon could choose to buy Hess’s 30% stake in the project or receive compensation from Chevron, thus changing the dynamics of the consortium in Guyana.

Impact on the oil market

The outcome of this case could also have wider implications for the global oil market. If Chevron succeeds in finalizing the acquisition of Hess, it will consolidate its position as a leader in the oil industry with increased access to Guyana’s reserves. This could stimulate investment in the development of the country’s oil infrastructure and attract more international partners.
On the other hand, a decision in favor of Exxon could set a precedent for pre-emptive rights in joint venture agreements, strengthening the positions of incumbents in the face of new acquisitions. This could also encourage companies to be even more vigilant when drafting and revising their contractual agreements, to avoid similar disputes in the future.
Guyana’s strategic importance for Chevron is undeniable, with oil reserves estimated at several billion barrels. The consolidation of these assets would considerably strengthen Chevron’s production capacity and its influence on the global oil market. However, the arbitration process and its potential legal and financial consequences remain a major obstacle to the completion of this acquisition.
The outcome of this arbitration is crucial not only for the parties directly involved, but also for the oil industry as a whole, as it could redefine the rules of the game when it comes to mergers and acquisitions in this sector. The outcome of this dispute could influence the way oil companies negotiate and structure their agreements in the future, with increased attention being paid to change-of-control clauses and pre-emption rights.
In short, the dispute between Chevron and Exxon Mobil over control of Hess’s assets in Guyana represents a turning point for the oil industry. The repercussions of this case will extend far beyond Guyana’s borders, influencing acquisition strategies, contractual relationships and power dynamics within the global energy sector.

Petro-Victory Energy announces the completion of drilling operations for the AND-5 well in the Andorinha field, Brazil, with positive reservoir results and next steps for production.
The Colombian prosecutor’s office has seized two offices belonging to the oil company Perenco in Bogotá. The company is accused of financing the United Self-Defense Forces of Colombia (AUC) in exchange for security services between 1997 and 2005.
Indonesia has signed a memorandum of understanding with the United States to increase its energy imports. This deal, involving Pertamina, aims to diversify the country's energy supply sources.
VAALCO Energy continues to operate the Baobab field by renovating its floating platform, despite modest production. This strategy aims to maintain stable profitability at low cost.
An empty reservoir exploded at a Lukoil-Perm oil facility in Russia, causing no injuries according to initial assessments pointing to a chemical reaction with oxygen as the cause of the accident.
The British Lindsey refinery has resumed fuel deliveries after reaching a temporary agreement to continue operations, while the future of this strategic site remains under insolvency proceedings.
BP and Shell intensify their commitments in Libya with new agreements aimed at revitalizing major oil field production, amid persistent instability but rising output in recent months.
The private OCP pipeline has resumed operations in Ecuador following an interruption caused by heavy rains, while the main SOTE pipeline remains shut down, continuing to impact oil exports from the South American country.
McDermott secures contract worth up to $50 million with BRAVA Energia to install subsea equipment on the Papa-Terra and Atlanta oil fields off the Brazilian coast.
Saudi Aramco increases its oil prices for Asia beyond initial expectations, reflecting strategic adjustments related to OPEC+ production and regional geopolitical uncertainties, with potential implications for Asian markets.
A bulk carrier operated by a Greek company sailing under a Liberian flag suffered a coordinated attack involving small arms and explosive drones, prompting an Israeli military response against Yemen's Houthis.
The Canadian government is now awaiting a concrete private-sector proposal to develop a new oil pipeline connecting Alberta to the Pacific coast, following recent legislation intended to expedite energy projects.
Petrobras is exploring various strategies for its Polo Bahia oil hub, including potentially selling it, as current profitability is challenged by oil prices around $65 per barrel.
Brazilian producer Azevedo & Travassos will issue new shares to buy Petro-Victory and its forty-nine concessions, consolidating its onshore presence while taking on net debt of about USD39.5mn.
Major oil producers accelerate their return to the market, raising their August quotas more sharply than initially expected, prompting questions about future market balances.
Lindsey refinery could halt operations within three weeks due to limited crude oil reserves, according to a recent analysis by energy consultancy Wood Mackenzie, highlighting an immediate slowdown in production.
The flow of crude between the Hamada field and the Zawiya refinery has resumed after emergency repairs, illustrating the mounting pressure on Libya’s ageing pipeline network that threatens the stability of domestic supply.
Libreville is intensifying the promotion of deep-water blocks, still seventy-two % unexplored, to offset the two hundred thousand barrels-per-day production drop recorded last year, according to GlobalData.
The African Export-Import Bank extends the Nigerian oil company’s facility, providing room to accelerate drilling and modernisation by 2029 as international lenders scale back hydrocarbon exposure.
Petronas begins a three-well exploratory drilling campaign offshore Suriname, deploying a Noble rig after securing an environmental permit and closely collaborating with state-owned company Staatsolie.