ASN-IRSN merger: Issues and debates at the French National Assembly

The reform of the ASN-IRSN merger is provoking crucial debate in the French National Assembly, highlighting the major nuclear safety issues at stake.

Share:

Sûreté nucléaire débat législatif

Gain full professional access to energynews.pro from 4.90$/month.
Designed for decision-makers, with no long-term commitment.

Over 30,000 articles published since 2021.
150 new market analyses every week to decode global energy trends.

Monthly Digital PRO PASS

Immediate Access
4.90$/month*

No commitment – cancel anytime, activation in 2 minutes.

*Special launch offer: 1st month at the indicated price, then 14.90 $/month, no long-term commitment.

Annual Digital PRO Pass

Full Annual Access
99$/year*

To access all of energynews.pro without any limits

*Introductory annual price for year one, automatically renewed at 149.00 $/year from the second year.

The proposed nuclear safety reform, aimed at merging the French Nuclear Safety Authority (ASN) and the French Institute for Radiological Protection and Nuclear Safety (IRSN), has sparked a new wave of debate in the French National Assembly. This proposal, part of a vast plan to revive nuclear power in France, aims to simplify and optimize the sector’s control and regulatory structures. Stated objectives include improving the responsiveness and efficiency of licensing and control processes, and consolidating expertise in radiation protection and safety. However, the approach raises serious concerns about the potential consequences for the independence and transparency of both entities, fundamental elements of public confidence in national nuclear safety.

Resistance and Concern about the Merger

The government’s proposal is thus encountering a broad spectrum of resistance, highlighting the different apprehensions of the players involved. The unions at both institutions, historically committed to protecting their members and defending the independence of their missions, are expressing their fear of a dilution of responsibilities and less clarity in decision-making processes. Political parties, from the left to certain segments of the majority, are alarmed at a possible erosion of the separation of powers between the regulatory bodies and the government, fearing increased executive influence over decisions crucial to nuclear safety.

Reactions and opposition

Opposition to the project manifests a diversity of arguments and perspectives. Voices have been raised, citing the risk of creating a less agile and less transparent super-entity, capable of compromising the rigor and objectivity required for nuclear oversight. The merger, seen by some as an attempt at budget rationalization, is also interpreted by others as a threat to the independence crucial to risk assessment and emergency management.
Arguments against the reform are based on the exemplary nature of the French nuclear safety model, often cited as a global benchmark. Critics of the project stress the importance of maintaining a clear distinction between the roles of ASN, as regulator and supervisor, and IRSN, as technical expert. They point to the danger that a merger would represent for this separation of functions, potentially damaging the effectiveness and objectivity of safety analyses.

Perspectives and implications

Beyond the immediate debates, the question of the ASN-IRSN merger raises broader issues of governance and the future of the nuclear sector in France. Against a backdrop of atomic revival and energy transition, the way France configures its nuclear watchdog institutions will have a major impact on public confidence, national security and energy policy. The decisions taken today will determine not only the architecture of nuclear regulation, but also the country’s ability to meet the challenges of safety and sustainable development.

The debate on the ASN-IRSN merger in the French National Assembly reflects the deep-rooted tensions and issues at stake in the French nuclear sector. Between the quest for efficiency and the preservation of independence and transparency, the reform highlights the challenges of nuclear governance and safety in a context of energy recovery. The outcome of these discussions will have significant implications for France’s nuclear strategy and public protection.

Terra Innovatum has signed a memorandum of understanding with Conuar for the supply of key components for the industrial production of its SOLO micro-modular reactor, marking a strategic move into the South American market.
Validation of underground injection permits by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency strengthens Dewey Burdock’s regulatory position and paves the way for state permitting expected in 2025.
Facing energy security challenges, several Southeast Asian countries are turning to nuclear and could invest up to $208bn to reach 25 GW of capacity, favouring small modular reactors.
A strategic partnership between the United Kingdom and the United States aims to shorten nuclear licensing timelines and strengthen industrial cooperation around fusion and modular reactors.
The International Atomic Energy Agency projects global nuclear capacity to reach 992 GW by 2050, driven by small modular reactors and lifetime extensions of existing plants.
Premier American Uranium and Nuclear Fuels have announced a target date of around September 19 to finalise their strategic consolidation, pending final approval from the TSX Venture Exchange.
The General Court of the European Union has rejected Austria’s appeal against the inclusion of gas and nuclear energy in the classification of sustainable investments.
Kazakhstan has signed an agreement with Nukem Technologies Engineering Services GmbH to benefit from German expertise in nuclear decommissioning and radioactive waste management.
The European Court of Justice annulled the European Commission's authorisation of Hungarian state aid for the Paks II nuclear project, questioning compliance with EU public procurement rules.
A Chinese consortium has secured a CNY4.2bn ($594mn) contract for the construction of conventional islands for the Xuwei nuclear project, combining third and fourth generation reactors.
Rosatom and China National Nuclear Corporation signed a memorandum of understanding to strengthen bilateral cooperation in talent development and skills training in the nuclear sector.
Iran has reached a new agreement with the International Atomic Energy Agency to formalise the resumption of inspections, following months of suspension linked to military tensions and criticism of its nuclear programme.
The French Energy Regulatory Commission outlines a structured plan to accelerate the deployment of small modular reactors, focusing on industrial heat and series effects to enhance competitiveness.
US-based Nuclearn has secured $10.5mn to scale its artificial intelligence platform, already deployed in over 65 nuclear reactors, to automate critical operations amid rising energy demand.
The steel dome of the CAP1000 Haiyang 4 reactor has been positioned, a major construction milestone paving the way for upcoming maintenance and technical installation phases.
The Groupement des Industriels Français de l'Énergie Nucléaire and the Belgian Nuclear Forum formalise a partnership aimed at strengthening industrial exchanges and joint projects between the two countries’ nuclear sectors.
The International Atomic Energy Agency warns that little time remains to reach an agreement with Iran on fully resuming inspections, as European sanctions could be reimposed within 30 days.
Slovenia’s JEK2 project moves forward with two nuclear technologies judged technically compatible, estimated between EUR9.31bn ($10.1bn) and EUR15.37bn ($16.66bn).
US-based Oklo will build the country’s first privately funded nuclear fuel recycling centre in Oak Ridge, investing $1.7bn and creating over 800 jobs.
The Tennessee Valley Authority partners with ENTRA1 Energy to develop up to 6 gigawatts of modular nuclear capacity, in an unprecedented project supporting energy growth across seven U.S. states.

Log in to read this article

You'll also have access to a selection of our best content.