Biofuel: WTO Arbitrates Malaysia-EU Dispute

Malaysia is challenging the European Union's restrictions on the use of palm oil in biofuels. The EU's "Red II" directive is at the heart of the dispute, as it excludes palm oil from the EU's energy targets, which Malaysia regards as a non-tariff trade barrier in breach of WTO rules.

Share:

Gain full professional access to energynews.pro from 4.90$/month.
Designed for decision-makers, with no long-term commitment.

Over 30,000 articles published since 2021.
150 new market analyses every week to decode global energy trends.

Monthly Digital PRO PASS

Immediate Access
4.90$/month*

No commitment – cancel anytime, activation in 2 minutes.

*Special launch offer: 1st month at the indicated price, then 14.90 $/month, no long-term commitment.

Annual Digital PRO Pass

Full Annual Access
99$/year*

To access all of energynews.pro without any limits

*Introductory annual price for year one, automatically renewed at 149.00 $/year from the second year.

Biofuels using palm oil are at the heart of a trade dispute between Malaysia and the European Union that the WTO is arbitrating. The Southeast Asian country criticizes the European organization for imposing excessive restrictions on the use of these fuels.

Biofuel: setting up a group of experts

According to Malaysia, certain measures imposed by the European Union (EU) are incompatible with international trade rules. The country made an initial request for arbitration in January, but this was refused by the EU. After this stalemate, the country finally obtained the setting up of a group of experts at theWorld Trade Organization (WTO).

Biofuel
An oil palm plantation in the state of Sabah, Borneo, Malaysia (Photo: Juan Carlos Munoz).

The European “Red II” directive as a brake on international trade

The European Red II directive is at the heart of this dispute. This does not include palm oil-based biofuel in the European Union’s energy objectives.

Its implementation would therefore result in a restriction on the use of palm oil. In Malaysia’s eyes, this would represent a non-tariff trade barrier, contrary to WTO rules.

An economic risk for 3 million workers

Malaysia, the world’s leading palm oil producer, wants above all to boost its exports. According to the Malaysian government, these blockades would lead to a deterioration in the living conditions of workers in the sector. Today, three million people are financially dependent on the oil trade.

An environmental controversy

Palm oil is currently the most widely used oil in the world, and is used in the composition of numerous products. However, environmental movements are critical of the effects of its production on deforestation and biodiversity. Indeed, in Malaysia, whole swathes of forest have been replaced in recent years by palm plantations.

To protect its palm oil exports, Malaysia turned to WTO arbitration. This will determine whether European regulations comply with international trade rules.

The federal government is granting $370mn to Canadian canola producers affected by a 75.8% tariff imposed by China, and is introducing fiscal and regulatory measures to strengthen the domestic biofuel industry.
Netherlands-based BTG Bioliquids and Canada’s NanosTech join forces to develop a modular solution for advanced biofuel production, with a project underway in Europe and Canada.
Teréga and GRDF have commissioned a backfeed station in Lot-et-Garonne, showcasing their cooperation to adapt gas networks to the rise of locally produced biomethane in Nouvelle-Aquitaine.
An Indonesian ministerial delegation visited China to explore waste-to-energy solutions, as the country moves forward with a $200mn project in Makassar.
Anaergia’s Italian subsidiary has been selected by Nortegas Renovables to build a biomethane facility in Andalusia using agricultural residues.
Mondi SCP will build a new biomass power plant in Ružomberok to boost energy self-sufficiency from 75% to 90% by 2027, with a €120mn ($129mn) investment supported by the European Union’s Modernisation Fund.
With a new EnviThan facility in Aube, EnviTec Biogas reaches 40 units in operation in France and confirms its deployment pace in the biomethane market.
Southwest Gas has submitted an agreement to the California Commission to inject biomethane produced from food and wastewater into its network, in line with SB 1440 regulatory requirements.
Quercus Real Assets and Elionia finalise a €76 mn bank financing to build three biomethane plants in Italy, with 50% of the debt guaranteed by SACE.
VINCI, through its subsidiaries, has established itself in the construction of Spain’s largest second-generation biorefinery, a €1.2bn project aimed at supplying 500,000 tonnes of sustainable fuels per year.
Ameresco commissions a biomethane facility in Lee County, processing 4,500 cubic feet of landfill gas per minute, and directly injects this renewable gas into the transmission network to reduce emissions and strengthen energy security.
A $24mn financing supports the construction of a 4.8 MW biomass plant designed to replace diesel in Opitciwan, bringing jobs and enhanced energy security for the Atikamekw community.
SUEZ and RATP Group formalise a supply contract for 100 GWh of renewable electricity per year, over a maximum period of sixteen years, powering the operations of the world’s third largest urban transport operator.
Valmet has secured a contract to supply a biomass boiler and flue gas cleaning system to Saica Group for its production site in El Burgo de Ebro, Spain, as part of its decarbonisation plan.
Qarlbo Biodiversity signed a memorandum of understanding with Woodland Biofuels for the delivery of thinned pine wood from managed forests in the United States to supply the Canadian company’s biomass operations.
The Canadian group Thermal Energy International has secured a CAD 1.4 million contract to install a heat recovery unit at a European malted barley producer, aiming to reduce energy costs and polluting emissions.
The asset takeover process of Global Bioenergies, under a pre-pack disposal procedure, has been extended until 18 July at noon, following requests from potential bidders seeking additional time to assess the French company's financial situation.
SIAAP and SUEZ have inaugurated a new biogas production unit at the Seine Aval wastewater treatment plant, the largest in Europe, as part of a modernization project to strengthen the energy sovereignty of the Paris region.
Canadian company Hydron Energy will supply its innovative INTRUPTor-Mid technology to produce renewable natural gas in Ontario, marking its first commercial order in the biomethane sector with a promise of significant cost reductions.
US President Donald Trump has ratified a law extending until the end of 2029 the tax credit on renewable natural gas production from biomass and animal manure, aiming to boost the rural economy.

Log in to read this article

You'll also have access to a selection of our best content.