popular articles

TotalEnergies and EDF: NGO actions upheld on appeal

The Paris Court of Appeal has ruled that the NGOs' actions against TotalEnergies and EDF are admissible, paving the way for an in-depth examination of these multinationals' due diligence plans.
Actions ONG contre multinationales

Please share:

The Paris Court of Appeal recently handed down landmark rulings concerning the actions brought by several NGOs against energy giants TotalEnergies and EDF. Greenpeace had already strongly criticized TotalEnergies’ role in the French nuclear sector. These actions are based on the duty of care, a legal requirement for multinationals to publish plans detailing the human and environmental risks of their activities. The court ruled that the associations’ claims were admissible, thus overturning the first-instance judgments.
These Court of Appeal rulings now allow cases to be examined on their merits, which could lead to significant changes in the way these companies manage their due diligence obligations. According to the court’s press release, the court declared certain plaintiffs admissible to act, thus enabling the debate on the merits of the measures requested before the Paris judicial court.

Background and legal implications

The 2017 French law on the duty of vigilance requires companies employing more than 5,000 employees in France and/or more than 10,000 worldwide to publish a vigilance plan. This plan must cover the human and environmental risks of their activities, including those of their foreign subsidiaries, subcontractors and suppliers. This legislation has positioned France as a leader in corporate social responsibility.
In one of the most high-profile cases, a coalition of NGOs and local authorities served formal notice on TotalEnergies, accusing it of failing to align its climate strategy with the Paris Agreement. Although rejected by the court of first instance for failing to respect the requirement of a prior dialogue phase, the NGOs had their claim upheld on appeal, opening up the possibility of a substantial review of TotalEnergies’ practices.

Specific decisions and future prospects

The Court of Appeal also ruled that the claims against EDF concerning a wind farm project in Mexico were admissible. Similarly, the management of water in the Chilean city of Osorno by a former Suez subsidiary, now part of Veolia, was examined. However, in the latter case, the court upheld the inadmissibility of the action, highlighting the strict criteria for identifying breaches required by law.
These judgments underline the importance of companies providing detailed due diligence plans that comply with legal requirements. They also highlight the increased vigilance of NGOs and local authorities, ready to take legal action to ensure that multinationals comply with environmental and social standards.
The implications of these decisions are far-reaching. They could reinforce the rigor with which multinationals develop and implement their vigilance plans. In addition, they provide a roadmap for NGOs and other stakeholders to hold companies accountable for their global impacts.
The forthcoming debates before the Paris judicial court promise to shed further light on the practical application of the Duty of Vigilance law, and could lead to influential legal precedents. This situation highlights the complex dynamic between companies’ legal obligations and growing expectations in terms of social and environmental responsibility.
In sum, these recent developments point to an intensification of efforts to enforce vigilance standards, and could mark a significant turning point in the way multinationals manage their global responsibilities.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

The province of Quebec is investing nearly $7.8 million to support six projects focused on critical and strategic minerals, thus advancing research to strengthen energy independence.
France proposes the creation of a European Decarbonization and Electrification Bank to support industrial companies facing the costs of energy transition. The project, backed by Bercy, aims for long-term financing and will be discussed at upcoming European Council meetings.
France proposes the creation of a European Decarbonization and Electrification Bank to support industrial companies facing the costs of energy transition. The project, backed by Bercy, aims for long-term financing and will be discussed at upcoming European Council meetings.
Paris supports maintaining regulated electricity tariffs for households and very small businesses despite criticism from the Competition Authority. A report sent to Brussels highlights their role in stabilizing the market.
Paris supports maintaining regulated electricity tariffs for households and very small businesses despite criticism from the Competition Authority. A report sent to Brussels highlights their role in stabilizing the market.
A network of anti-competitive agreements and corruption surrounding electrification in Réunion is bringing eight individuals and two companies to trial in May. Practices that distorted public tenders have already led to several convictions and financial penalties.
A network of anti-competitive agreements and corruption surrounding electrification in Réunion is bringing eight individuals and two companies to trial in May. Practices that distorted public tenders have already led to several convictions and financial penalties.
Europe's energy transition is driving a structural transformation of the electricity grid, exposing the market to new vulnerabilities. A study by Compass Lexecon highlights three strategic levers to ensure supply stability amid geopolitical pressures and market volatility.
The Gulf Cooperation Council Interconnection Authority (GCCIA) and the Qatar Fund for Development (QDF) have signed a $100 million financing agreement to connect the Gulf power grid with Oman. This strategic project, with a total cost exceeding $700 million, aims to enhance regional energy security and efficiency.
The Gulf Cooperation Council Interconnection Authority (GCCIA) and the Qatar Fund for Development (QDF) have signed a $100 million financing agreement to connect the Gulf power grid with Oman. This strategic project, with a total cost exceeding $700 million, aims to enhance regional energy security and efficiency.
Liberia Electricity Corporation (LEC), in partnership with the European Union and other financial institutions, has launched the Liberia Energy Efficiency and Access Project (LEEAP). With a budget of €107 million, this initiative aims to improve electricity access and energy efficiency in the country.
Liberia Electricity Corporation (LEC), in partnership with the European Union and other financial institutions, has launched the Liberia Energy Efficiency and Access Project (LEEAP). With a budget of €107 million, this initiative aims to improve electricity access and energy efficiency in the country.
Energy Minister Marc Ferracci reaffirmed his opposition to reopening the debate on oil exploration in France. Despite proposals from Overseas Minister Manuel Valls, the government is prioritizing a decarbonization strategy aligned with its international commitments.
Energy Minister Marc Ferracci reaffirmed his opposition to reopening the debate on oil exploration in France. Despite proposals from Overseas Minister Manuel Valls, the government is prioritizing a decarbonization strategy aligned with its international commitments.
Donald Trump has signed a decree creating a National Council for Energy Dominance, aimed at massively increasing electricity production. The goal is to strengthen the United States’ competitiveness in artificial intelligence (AI), a rapidly expanding and energy-intensive sector.
*Thames Water, a major water supplier in the UK, is facing an environmental investigation over growing concerns regarding its waste management and leaks. This situation raises significant financial stakes for the company.*
*Thames Water, a major water supplier in the UK, is facing an environmental investigation over growing concerns regarding its waste management and leaks. This situation raises significant financial stakes for the company.*
The Medef and thirteen other European employers' organizations launch an initiative to support the nuclear sector in the EU, in response to increasing competitiveness challenges exacerbated by international politics and global economic tensions.
The Medef and thirteen other European employers' organizations launch an initiative to support the nuclear sector in the EU, in response to increasing competitiveness challenges exacerbated by international politics and global economic tensions.
France will invest €100 billion to modernize its power grid by 2035. However, the impact on consumer bills will be limited, according to the network manager RTE.
France will invest €100 billion to modernize its power grid by 2035. However, the impact on consumer bills will be limited, according to the network manager RTE.
The Watt For Change Foundation and the French Development Agency are joining forces to support three initiatives aimed at improving access to renewable energy in Benin, Mauritania, and Madagascar. A €860,000 three-year partnership dedicated to assisting local associations.
The Tanzanian government plans to invest $12.9 billion to add 2.4 GW to its power grid by 2030. This funding aims to expand electricity access to 75% of the population, with significant participation from the private sector.
The Tanzanian government plans to invest $12.9 billion to add 2.4 GW to its power grid by 2030. This funding aims to expand electricity access to 75% of the population, with significant participation from the private sector.
A court demands that all funding linked to federal energy and climate laws, previously suspended, be immediately put back into circulation. This decision is based on a federal judgment challenging the legality of a freeze imposed by the American executive.
A court demands that all funding linked to federal energy and climate laws, previously suspended, be immediately put back into circulation. This decision is based on a federal judgment challenging the legality of a freeze imposed by the American executive.
At the World Summit on Artificial Intelligence in Paris, Emmanuel Macron highlighted nuclear energy as a power source for technological infrastructures, countering Donald Trump's plans to massively expand oil drilling in the United States.
At the World Summit on Artificial Intelligence in Paris, Emmanuel Macron highlighted nuclear energy as a power source for technological infrastructures, countering Donald Trump's plans to massively expand oil drilling in the United States.
Canada will need to build energy infrastructure on an unprecedented scale to meet the federal government's goal of eliminating greenhouse gas emissions from the electricity sector by 2050. A major technical and economic challenge marked by delays and significant costs.
The majority of countries have not submitted their new climate roadmaps to the UN before the February 10 deadline. This delay raises questions about the priorities of major economies amid geopolitical shifts and economic uncertainty.
The majority of countries have not submitted their new climate roadmaps to the UN before the February 10 deadline. This delay raises questions about the priorities of major economies amid geopolitical shifts and economic uncertainty.
Joseph Saddi is the new Minister of Energy in Lebanon. He inherits a sector weakened by reliance on imports and failing infrastructure, while international partnerships struggle to restart oil and gas exploration.
Joseph Saddi is the new Minister of Energy in Lebanon. He inherits a sector weakened by reliance on imports and failing infrastructure, while international partnerships struggle to restart oil and gas exploration.
Rosatom announces the development of a plasma rocket engine prototype capable of reducing the journey to Mars to just 30 days. This technological breakthrough could have major strategic implications in the race for space exploration.
Rosatom announces the development of a plasma rocket engine prototype capable of reducing the journey to Mars to just 30 days. This technological breakthrough could have major strategic implications in the race for space exploration.
Electricity consumption in France increased by 0.7% in 2024, reaching 449.2 terawatt-hours, according to RTE. This slight rise marks a turning point after two years of decline but remains well below pre-2020 levels.
The National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC) has announced a reduction in renewable energy subsidies in China. New projects will now have to sell their electricity at market prices, marking a transition to a more autonomous economic model.
The National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC) has announced a reduction in renewable energy subsidies in China. New projects will now have to sell their electricity at market prices, marking a transition to a more autonomous economic model.
Lithuania, Estonia, and Latvia have finalized their synchronization with the European electricity grid, ending their dependence on Russian infrastructure. This project, funded with €1.6 billion, strengthens the region’s energy security.
Lithuania, Estonia, and Latvia have finalized their synchronization with the European electricity grid, ending their dependence on Russian infrastructure. This project, funded with €1.6 billion, strengthens the region’s energy security.
French electricity exports generated a record €5 billion in 2024, driven by increased volumes despite falling market prices. Italy, Germany, and Belgium are among the main importers.
French electricity exports generated a record €5 billion in 2024, driven by increased volumes despite falling market prices. Italy, Germany, and Belgium are among the main importers.

Advertising