popular articles

TotalEnergies and EDF: NGO actions upheld on appeal

The Paris Court of Appeal has ruled that the NGOs' actions against TotalEnergies and EDF are admissible, paving the way for an in-depth examination of these multinationals' due diligence plans.
Actions ONG contre multinationales

Please share:

The Paris Court of Appeal recently handed down landmark rulings concerning the actions brought by several NGOs against energy giants TotalEnergies and EDF. Greenpeace had already strongly criticized TotalEnergies’ role in the French nuclear sector. These actions are based on the duty of care, a legal requirement for multinationals to publish plans detailing the human and environmental risks of their activities. The court ruled that the associations’ claims were admissible, thus overturning the first-instance judgments.
These Court of Appeal rulings now allow cases to be examined on their merits, which could lead to significant changes in the way these companies manage their due diligence obligations. According to the court’s press release, the court declared certain plaintiffs admissible to act, thus enabling the debate on the merits of the measures requested before the Paris judicial court.

Background and legal implications

The 2017 French law on the duty of vigilance requires companies employing more than 5,000 employees in France and/or more than 10,000 worldwide to publish a vigilance plan. This plan must cover the human and environmental risks of their activities, including those of their foreign subsidiaries, subcontractors and suppliers. This legislation has positioned France as a leader in corporate social responsibility.
In one of the most high-profile cases, a coalition of NGOs and local authorities served formal notice on TotalEnergies, accusing it of failing to align its climate strategy with the Paris Agreement. Although rejected by the court of first instance for failing to respect the requirement of a prior dialogue phase, the NGOs had their claim upheld on appeal, opening up the possibility of a substantial review of TotalEnergies’ practices.

Specific decisions and future prospects

The Court of Appeal also ruled that the claims against EDF concerning a wind farm project in Mexico were admissible. Similarly, the management of water in the Chilean city of Osorno by a former Suez subsidiary, now part of Veolia, was examined. However, in the latter case, the court upheld the inadmissibility of the action, highlighting the strict criteria for identifying breaches required by law.
These judgments underline the importance of companies providing detailed due diligence plans that comply with legal requirements. They also highlight the increased vigilance of NGOs and local authorities, ready to take legal action to ensure that multinationals comply with environmental and social standards.
The implications of these decisions are far-reaching. They could reinforce the rigor with which multinationals develop and implement their vigilance plans. In addition, they provide a roadmap for NGOs and other stakeholders to hold companies accountable for their global impacts.
The forthcoming debates before the Paris judicial court promise to shed further light on the practical application of the Duty of Vigilance law, and could lead to influential legal precedents. This situation highlights the complex dynamic between companies’ legal obligations and growing expectations in terms of social and environmental responsibility.
In sum, these recent developments point to an intensification of efforts to enforce vigilance standards, and could mark a significant turning point in the way multinationals manage their global responsibilities.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

The new American plan aims for a 66% reduction in emissions by 2035, focusing on local policies and investments in clean energy, with significant implications for markets and regulation.
The Inter-American Court of Human Rights has condemned Colombia for violating U'wa rights by approving seven energy projects impacting 370 km of their protected ancestral lands.
The Inter-American Court of Human Rights has condemned Colombia for violating U'wa rights by approving seven energy projects impacting 370 km of their protected ancestral lands.
Green electricity outages in Germany jeopardize Olaf Scholz’s energy policy. Amid internal criticism and European tensions, the German model is under scrutiny ahead of the legislative elections.
Green electricity outages in Germany jeopardize Olaf Scholz’s energy policy. Amid internal criticism and European tensions, the German model is under scrutiny ahead of the legislative elections.
Spanish lawmakers rejected the continuation of an exceptional tax on energy companies, highlighting significant parliamentary disagreement and raising concerns about the future of investments tied to the country's energy transition.
Spanish lawmakers rejected the continuation of an exceptional tax on energy companies, highlighting significant parliamentary disagreement and raising concerns about the future of investments tied to the country's energy transition.
Starting July 2025, a European label will allow passengers to compare CO2 emissions from flights, aiming to promote less polluting options.
The UK electricity grid operator, National Grid, announces an ambitious £35 billion plan to double electricity transmission capacity by 2031, in alignment with the government's environmental goals.
The UK electricity grid operator, National Grid, announces an ambitious £35 billion plan to double electricity transmission capacity by 2031, in alignment with the government's environmental goals.
Nigeria approves Shell's $2.4 billion sale of 30% onshore assets
Nigeria approves Shell's $2.4 billion sale of 30% onshore assets
The Department of Energy grants a conditional $15 billion loan to PG&E to modernize California's infrastructure. This project is part of a larger effort to transform regional energy policy.
The Department of Energy grants a conditional $15 billion loan to PG&E to modernize California's infrastructure. This project is part of a larger effort to transform regional energy policy.
Germany’s energy policy, marked by the nuclear phase-out, has driven electricity prices up in Sweden, affecting households and businesses. Stockholm accuses Berlin of neglecting regional impacts and suspends a key interconnection project.
A project supported by the UNDP and the European Union aims to reduce energy losses and modernize Kazakhstan's electric infrastructure, the largest greenhouse gas emitter in Central Asia.
A project supported by the UNDP and the European Union aims to reduce energy losses and modernize Kazakhstan's electric infrastructure, the largest greenhouse gas emitter in Central Asia.
The Court of Audit reveals €200 billion in investment needs to modernize French electrical grids by 2040, urging a balance between shareholder and consumer financial efforts.
The Court of Audit reveals €200 billion in investment needs to modernize French electrical grids by 2040, urging a balance between shareholder and consumer financial efforts.
Donald Trump's proposal to impose a 25% tariff on all imports from Canada and Mexico risks disrupting supply chains and increasing costs for American businesses and consumers.
Donald Trump's proposal to impose a 25% tariff on all imports from Canada and Mexico risks disrupting supply chains and increasing costs for American businesses and consumers.
Reforms aimed at accelerating energy permits have been excluded from the U.S. budget bill, postponing discussions to a Republican-led Congress that plans more ambitious changes.
The U.S. Supreme Court reviews the fuel industry’s challenge against California’s exclusive right to impose electric vehicle sales targets, a key issue for national emission standards.
The U.S. Supreme Court reviews the fuel industry’s challenge against California’s exclusive right to impose electric vehicle sales targets, a key issue for national emission standards.
Japan plans to reduce its reliance on thermal energy to 30%-40% by fiscal year 2040-2041 while significantly increasing renewable energy, according to a draft Strategic Energy Plan.
Japan plans to reduce its reliance on thermal energy to 30%-40% by fiscal year 2040-2041 while significantly increasing renewable energy, according to a draft Strategic Energy Plan.
In response to climate pressures, the Biden administration proposes limiting public support for oil and gas projects abroad. An initiative that could redefine global energy policy.
In response to climate pressures, the Biden administration proposes limiting public support for oil and gas projects abroad. An initiative that could redefine global energy policy.
Niger has received a 20 MW diesel power plant as a strategic donation from Morocco. This project aims to strengthen local production in a context marked by high dependency on Nigeria for energy supply.
The Zawiya refinery, essential for fuel supply in Libya, has suspended its activities after armed clashes caused significant fires and sparked a local crisis.
The Zawiya refinery, essential for fuel supply in Libya, has suspended its activities after armed clashes caused significant fires and sparked a local crisis.
Despite corruption charges against Gautam Adani, CEO of the eponymous conglomerate, Sri Lanka confirms the continuation of the strategic Colombo container terminal project, vital for its struggling economy.
Despite corruption charges against Gautam Adani, CEO of the eponymous conglomerate, Sri Lanka confirms the continuation of the strategic Colombo container terminal project, vital for its struggling economy.
Faced with the threat of Russian gas cuts, Moldova is enacting a 60-day state of emergency to safeguard its energy security and prevent a humanitarian crisis during one of the most critical winters for its energy independence.
Faced with the threat of Russian gas cuts, Moldova is enacting a 60-day state of emergency to safeguard its energy security and prevent a humanitarian crisis during one of the most critical winters for its energy independence.
Utah Governor Spencer Cox proposes an ambitious budget to double energy production within ten years, focusing on nuclear and geothermal energy, contrasting with federal priorities on solar energy.
Energy prices in Europe far exceed those in the United States and China, putting the manufacturing industry at a disadvantage. An urgent review of energy and industrial policies is needed to safeguard European competitiveness.
Energy prices in Europe far exceed those in the United States and China, putting the manufacturing industry at a disadvantage. An urgent review of energy and industrial policies is needed to safeguard European competitiveness.
SSE Transmission submits an ambitious plan to Ofgem, aiming for £22 billion in investments to support energy transition, create thousands of jobs, and strengthen Scotland's electricity infrastructure.
SSE Transmission submits an ambitious plan to Ofgem, aiming for £22 billion in investments to support energy transition, create thousands of jobs, and strengthen Scotland's electricity infrastructure.
The Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam offers hope for Ethiopia's energy needs and challenges for Egypt and Sudan's water security. Collaborative management is crucial to prevent crises in the Nile Basin.
The Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam offers hope for Ethiopia's energy needs and challenges for Egypt and Sudan's water security. Collaborative management is crucial to prevent crises in the Nile Basin.

Advertising