Germany suspends carbon credits in China on suspicion of massive fraud

Germany blocks emission reduction certificates for projects in China after detecting irregularities, calling into question the reliability of carbon offsets on the European market.

Share:

Logo de

Comprehensive energy news coverage, updated nonstop

Annual subscription

8.25$/month*

*billed annually at 99$/year for the first year then 149,00$/year ​

Unlimited access • Archives included • Professional invoice

OTHER ACCESS OPTIONS

Monthly subscription

Unlimited access • Archives included

5.2$/month*
then 14.90$ per month thereafter

FREE ACCOUNT

3 articles offered per month

FREE

*Prices are excluding VAT, which may vary depending on your location or professional status

Since 2021: 35,000 articles • 150+ analyses per week

Germany’s Federal Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt, UBA) has suspended the award of reduced emissions certificates for eight Chinese carbon offset projects following the discovery of serious “irregularities”.
These projects, designed to reduce the CO2 emissions of European companies by financing initiatives abroad, failed to meet transparency and verification requirements.
Some projects, involving oil companies, were never carried out, while others exaggerated the results obtained.
These irregularities led to the immediate suspension of certificates for seven projects presenting “legal and technical inconsistencies”, as well as for an eighth project for non-compliance with validation rules.
The UBA has extended its investigations to 40 of the 69 emission reduction projects in China.
Twenty-one of these projects are under strong suspicion of fraud, prompting UBA to enlist the help of an international law firm to determine the extent of manipulation.
In collaboration with the Berlin public prosecutor’s office, UBA is seeking to clarify the responsibilities and potential implications of these irregularities, which could seriously affect the validity of carbon credits used on the European market.

Compensation mechanisms and verification failures

Carbon credits, as defined by the Kyoto Protocol’s Emission Reduction Units (ERUs), enable companies to offset their CO2 emissions by financing projects abroad.
These credits must represent real, verifiable reductions in greenhouse gas emissions.
However, recent events in Germany have highlighted major flaws in the validation processes for these credits, particularly when audits are carried out by private bodies.
Several companies specializing in environmental audits have also been targeted, following searches carried out last July at the request of the Berlin public prosecutor’s office.
These actions illustrate the authorities’ determination to improve supervision of these projects, often criticized for their opacity and lack of transparency.
Weaknesses in the validation of carbon credits raise serious questions about the reliability of these market instruments, which are crucial to achieving international climate targets.
The potential financial damage of this fraud is estimated at 4.5 billion euros, an amount based on unpaid fines by companies that have falsified their emissions reduction reports.
This situation has prompted the UBA to suspend the approval of new emission reduction projects in China since July 1, in a bid to restore confidence in carbon offset mechanisms.

Financial and regulatory implications

Germany’s freeze on carbon credits highlights the risks associated with delegating audits to potentially non-independent entities.
German and European regulators are increasingly being called upon to review project validation criteria and tighten the conditions for awarding carbon credits.
The market’s credibility depends on the authorities’ ability to implement more rigorous transparency and verification measures to prevent abuses.
The voluntary carbon credit market, already weakened by dubious practices, could also be affected by this crisis of confidence.
Credit prices and liquidity have been impacted, and lower-quality projects are facing increasing criticism.
Solutions such as diversifying offset methods, including methane collection and technological carbon capture projects, are being considered, but require rigorous audits and solid proof of emission reductions to maintain their credibility.

Outlook for the European carbon credit market

Revelations of carbon credit fraud in China are prompting regulators to adopt stricter measures and strengthen their validation requirements.
Cooperation between regulators, governments and companies will be essential to ensure the integrity of carbon offset mechanisms.
The market must adapt to more rigorous regulation, where compliance and transparency will be indispensable criteria.
Companies must be prepared for more frequent audits and stiffer penalties in the event of non-compliance.
The European carbon credit market, essential to strategies to combat climate change, must regain the confidence of investors and industry players alike.
Tighter regulation, combined with more rigorous monitoring, could help stabilize this fast-growing but still vulnerable market.

The price of nature-based carbon credits dropped to $13.30/mtCO2e in October as a 94% surge in September issuances far outpaced corporate demand.
Driven by the energy, heavy industry and power generation sectors, the global carbon capture and storage market could reach $6.6bn by 2034, supported by an annual growth rate of 5.8%.
Article 6 converts carbon credits into a compliance asset, driven by sovereign purchases, domestic markets, and sectoral schemes, with annual demand projected above 700 Mt and supply constrained by timelines, levies, and CA requirements.
The GOCO2 project enters public consultation with six industrial players united around a 375 km network aiming to capture, transport and export 2.2 million tonnes of CO2 per year starting in 2031.
TotalEnergies reduced its stake in the Bifrost CO2 storage project in Denmark, bringing in CarbonVault as an industrial partner and future client of the offshore site located in the North Sea.
The United Kingdom is launching the construction of two industrial carbon capture projects, backed by £9.4bn ($11.47bn) in public funding, with 500 skilled jobs created in the north of the country.
Frontier Infrastructure, in partnership with Gevo and Verity, rolls out an integrated solution combining rail transport, permanent sequestration, and digital CO₂ tracking, targeting over 200 ethanol production sites in North America.
geoLOGIC and Carbon Management Canada launch a free online technical certificate to support industrial sectors involved in carbon capture and storage technologies.
AtmosClear has chosen ExxonMobil to handle the transport and storage of 680,000 tonnes of CO₂ per year from its future biomass energy site at the Port of Baton Rouge, United States.
The Dutch start-up secures €6.8mn to industrialise a DAC electrolyser coupled with hydrogen, targeting sub-$100 per tonne capture and a €1.8mn European grant.
Japan Petroleum Exploration is preparing two offshore exploratory drillings near Hokkaidō to assess the feasibility of CO₂ storage as part of the Tomakomai CCS project.
The Singaporean government has signed a contract to purchase 2.17 million mtCO2e of carbon credits from REDD+, reforestation and grassland restoration projects, with deliveries scheduled between 2026 and 2030.
The Canadian government is funding three companies specialising in CO2 capture and utilisation, as part of a strategy to develop local technologies with high industrial value.
European carbon allowance prices reached a six-month high, driven by industrial compliance buying ahead of the deadline and rising natural gas costs.
Zefiro Methane Corp. completed the delivery of carbon credits to EDF Trading, validating a pre-sale agreement and marking its first revenues from the voluntary carbon market.
Hanwha Power Systems has signed a contract to supply mechanical vapour recompression compressors for a European combined-cycle power plant integrating carbon capture and storage.
A prudent limit of 1,460 GtCO2 for geologic storage reshapes the split between industrial abatement and net removals, with oil-scale injection needs and an onshore/offshore distribution that will define logistics, costs and liabilities.
Frontier Infrastructure Holdings drilled a 5,618-metre well in Wyoming, setting a national record and strengthening the Sweetwater Carbon Storage Hub’s potential for industrial carbon dioxide storage.
The Northern Lights project has injected its first volume of CO2 under the North Sea, marking an industrial milestone for carbon transport and storage in Europe.
Verra and S&P Global Commodity Insights join forces to build a next-generation registry aimed at strengthening carbon market integration and enhancing transaction transparency.

All the latest energy news, all the time

Annual subscription

8.25$/month*

*billed annually at 99$/year for the first year then 149,00$/year ​

Unlimited access - Archives included - Pro invoice

Monthly subscription

Unlimited access • Archives included

5.2$/month*
then 14.90$ per month thereafter

*Prices shown are exclusive of VAT, which may vary according to your location or professional status.

Since 2021: 30,000 articles - +150 analyses/week.