popular articles

Future of electricity: Cour des Comptes warns of “uncertainties” surrounding nuclear power

Please share:

The French State Audit Office (Cour des Comptes) warned on Thursday of the “uncertainties” surrounding the ability to build a new nuclear fleet “within reasonable timescales and at reasonable costs”, just as President Macron has decided to launch a new EPR program.
The construction of new means of electricity production – whether nuclear or renewable – “calls for decisions that are now urgent to guarantee our supply by the decade 2040”, the magistrates emphasize in a thematic note.
This was already the conclusion of the recent report by grid operator RTE, at a time when France’s nuclear fleet is ageing and electricity needs must increase to reduce the use of fossil fuels.
Following the report’s publication, Emmanuel Macron announced on November 9 the launch of a new nuclear power program, a topic that had become a key issue in the run-up to the 2022 presidential election.
France is currently building a single new-generation EPR reactor at Flamanville (Manche).
Recalling “the slippage in construction times” for the latter, the Court highlights “uncertainty in terms of the ability to build a new fleet of reactors within reasonable timescales and at reasonable costs.”
EDF has made a proposal to the French government to initially build 6 new EPR models (EPR2) at an estimated construction cost of 46 billion euros.
But the magistrates note that many more would be needed (up to “25 to 30”) to maintain a 50% nuclear share of electricity production beyond 2050.
This would require “an accelerated mobilization and recovery effort by our nuclear industry” and would raise “the question of the number of available sites”.
They also point out that EDF alone will not be able to finance new construction, and that “risk sharing with the State” will be necessary.
But it’s not just nuclear power that raises questions: “the challenges facing new renewable energies appear to be just as great”, notes the report.
Even if there is no technological uncertainty with wind and solar power, they face other challenges, such as storage and siting difficulties.
The Court concludes by calling for a debate “on a more informed basis”, given that there is in particular “a significant risk for public finances”.
“There is no simple decision, no low-cost solution, no zero risk”, stress the authors.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

The U.S. Department of Energy will purchase three litres of helium-3 from Interlune by 2029, marking the first public contract involving a natural resource extracted from the lunar surface.
Iran will limit daily power cuts to two hours for households starting May 10, aiming to ease pressure on the national electricity grid as temperatures climb.
Iran will limit daily power cuts to two hours for households starting May 10, aiming to ease pressure on the national electricity grid as temperatures climb.
The French government has entrusted Bernard Fontana with the leadership of EDF, relying on his industrial background to manage the end of the Arenh and revive the nuclear programme.
The French government has entrusted Bernard Fontana with the leadership of EDF, relying on his industrial background to manage the end of the Arenh and revive the nuclear programme.
Germany’s new Economy Minister, Katherina Reiche, plans 20 gigawatts of gas-fired plants to address the limits of renewable energy.
Germany’s new Economy Minister, Katherina Reiche, plans 20 gigawatts of gas-fired plants to address the limits of renewable energy.
The Spanish Prime Minister has asked for more time to determine the causes of an unprecedented outage on April 28 that cut 15 gigawatts of electricity from the peninsula’s grid.
Prime Minister François Bayrou confirmed that France’s 2025–2035 energy roadmap remains under discussion and will only be finalised after parliamentary debates starting on 16 June.
Prime Minister François Bayrou confirmed that France’s 2025–2035 energy roadmap remains under discussion and will only be finalised after parliamentary debates starting on 16 June.
The re-election of the Albanese government reassures energy stakeholders calling for regulatory adjustments to accelerate projects and secure long-term investment.
The re-election of the Albanese government reassures energy stakeholders calling for regulatory adjustments to accelerate projects and secure long-term investment.
SOGARA is launching a two-phase modernisation programme to increase the country's energy autonomy by 2030, with financing primarily from external sources.
SOGARA is launching a two-phase modernisation programme to increase the country's energy autonomy by 2030, with financing primarily from external sources.
Suriname has launched a pre-distribution programme of its future oil revenues, offering a $750 bonus to more than 570,000 citizens well before the start of offshore production scheduled for 2028.
One week after the massive blackout, Spain and Portugal continue their investigations with no technical conclusion, while Madrid calls on France to accelerate cross-border interconnection projects.
One week after the massive blackout, Spain and Portugal continue their investigations with no technical conclusion, while Madrid calls on France to accelerate cross-border interconnection projects.
Australia’s opposition leader unveils a seven-reactor plan, challenging current energy policy days before federal elections and reviving a decades-old debate.
Australia’s opposition leader unveils a seven-reactor plan, challenging current energy policy days before federal elections and reviving a decades-old debate.
The French Energy Regulatory Commission proposes reducing certain renewable generation targets due to a slower-than-expected rise in electricity demand.
The French Energy Regulatory Commission proposes reducing certain renewable generation targets due to a slower-than-expected rise in electricity demand.
Nominated to lead EDF, Bernard Fontana aims to restore dialogue with electro-intensive industries and oversee the nuclear revival while ensuring the group’s financial sustainability.
Two days after a blackout that disrupted 60% of national demand, the growing share of renewables in Spain’s grid faces strong political and industrial criticism.
Two days after a blackout that disrupted 60% of national demand, the growing share of renewables in Spain’s grid faces strong political and industrial criticism.
The NGO Reclaim Finance ranked BPCE last among twenty major European banks for its lack of commitment to the transition towards carbon neutrality, according to a study published on Tuesday.
The NGO Reclaim Finance ranked BPCE last among twenty major European banks for its lack of commitment to the transition towards carbon neutrality, according to a study published on Tuesday.
François Bayrou plans to postpone the publication of the French energy decree until the end of the summer after parliamentary review, under pressure from the Rassemblement National and part of the right.
François Bayrou plans to postpone the publication of the French energy decree until the end of the summer after parliamentary review, under pressure from the Rassemblement National and part of the right.
The European Investment Bank signs a loan of over €525mn with PGE to develop solar projects and modernise a power plant in Poland.
Argentina initiates Enarsa's privatization to redefine the state's role toward stronger regulation, paving the way for increased private investment in the national energy sector amid significant industrial and commercial transformation.
Argentina initiates Enarsa's privatization to redefine the state's role toward stronger regulation, paving the way for increased private investment in the national energy sector amid significant industrial and commercial transformation.
The British environmental movement Just Stop Oil organised its final march in London on Saturday, announcing the end of its spectacular actions against new oil and gas projects in the United Kingdom.
The British environmental movement Just Stop Oil organised its final march in London on Saturday, announcing the end of its spectacular actions against new oil and gas projects in the United Kingdom.
The Dutch government is unlocking €11.4 billion aimed at securing industrial energy supplies, strengthening electricity infrastructure, and accelerating civilian nuclear development, in response to current economic and energy constraints.
The Dutch government is unlocking €11.4 billion aimed at securing industrial energy supplies, strengthening electricity infrastructure, and accelerating civilian nuclear development, in response to current economic and energy constraints.
Hydro-Québec announces a 10 G$ investment to enhance energy efficiency through various initiatives by 2035, creating over 5,000 jobs and reducing operating costs for Quebec customers.
The UK government and Italian energy company Eni have announced the financial closing of a project aimed at burying millions of tonnes of CO2 in the Irish Sea, an ambitious initiative to reduce industrial emissions.
The UK government and Italian energy company Eni have announced the financial closing of a project aimed at burying millions of tonnes of CO2 in the Irish Sea, an ambitious initiative to reduce industrial emissions.
The United States strongly criticised anti-fossil fuel policies at the International Energy Agency (IEA) summit, highlighting their dangers to global energy security.
The United States strongly criticised anti-fossil fuel policies at the International Energy Agency (IEA) summit, highlighting their dangers to global energy security.
Countries such as Brazil and Australia are criticised for overstating the CO2 absorption capacity of their forests, a practice that undermines their commitment to reducing greenhouse gas emissions, according to a report by Climate Analytics.
Countries such as Brazil and Australia are criticised for overstating the CO2 absorption capacity of their forests, a practice that undermines their commitment to reducing greenhouse gas emissions, according to a report by Climate Analytics.

Advertising