France: In Paris, the very official debate on nuclear power turns short

"Do we need a new nuclear reactor program?": some 240 people discussed this topic at a meeting in Paris.

Share:

“Do we need a new nuclear reactor program?”: some 240 people discussed this topic in Paris at a meeting organized by the very official National Commission for Public Debate (CNDP), a debate which, however, often left them wanting more.

“The public debate on nuclear power has been biased since the beginning. It is just a formality of the State, it will have no impact”, deplores Tom Dury, 28 years old, even before the discussion starts in the premises of the House of solidarity associations of the 13th district.

This young unemployed man and other activists, dressed in white suits to symbolize their opposition to nuclear power, traveled from the Meuse to denounce the project to bury highly radioactive waste in Bure, a town in this rural department.

In their hands, funeral wreaths flocked “Chernobyl 1986”, “Fukushima 2011” or “Penly 2035”.

EDF plans to build three pairs of new generation EPR2 nuclear reactors, the first of which is scheduled to be commissioned at the Penly site in 2035.

Announcing this vast project to revive nuclear power in Belfort in February, Emmanuel Macron had specified that eight additional reactors were under study.

Ten public meetings will be organized between now and February 27 throughout France by the CNDP, an independent authority that must summarize the results to “enlighten” parliamentarians. The first was held on October 27 in Dieppe, not far from the Penly site.

A few meters away from the Bure activists, members of the “Piscine Nucléaire Stop” collective are protesting against a new spent nuclear fuel storage project to be built near the La Hague waste reprocessing plant (Manche).

“So how are we going to debate? Will we listen to the complicit representatives of EDF and RTE (the French high voltage network manager, editor’s note) present their big projects in a delicate language of wood, discuss small details that they have omitted to refine?”, Théo Le Bruman thunders behind his megaphone.

Few citizens

In the room, the atmosphere is studious and very masculine, each participant being assigned in no particular order to one of the 24 tables.

Among them, a handful of local elected officials and curious citizens but mostly anti-nuclear and pro-nuclear. Another 600 have connected remotely.

At table number 15, seven men and one woman listened to the keynote speech by Michel Badré, president of the public debate, on the framework of this consultation. Then the clock starts: forty minutes to take turns on the question of the day.

But when the debate starts, it quickly turns into a short one at table 15. The seven men and one woman who sat around were all largely in favor of building new nuclear reactors. “We are the consensus table,” one of them even squeaks.

Martin Boissavit, 34, a nuclear engineer, said he was “a little disappointed” by this express debate, which in the end was not a debate at all, confining itself to “very technical” questions that nipped the “real societal debate” in the bud.

Like the other debaters of the evening, he will have spent more time listening to the interventions of the representatives of EDF and other organizations on the different energy scenarios than exchanging views.

A debate for nothing? “In any case, the consensus in favor of the nuclear park has already passed in Parliament,” he says.

The next public debate will take place on November 22 in Saclay (Essonne), a leading centre for nuclear research, on a no less technical theme: “What is the EPR2, and can we do nuclear power differently?

Tehran agrees to host experts from the International Atomic Energy Agency in the coming weeks, excluding any visit to sensitive sites as diplomatic tensions persist with European nations and the United States.
Standard Uranium announces the results of a high-resolution electromagnetic survey at the Corvo project, confirming 29 kilometres of conductive corridors and launching the planning of an inaugural drilling programme for 2026.
NANO Nuclear Energy assembles and tests its annular induction pump prototype, marking progress for its microreactor programmes and paving the way for potential commercialisation of the technology.
Hungary reaffirms its intent to double the capacity of its Paks nuclear power plant in partnership with Rosatom, with concrete works expected to begin in the autumn.
Arabelle Solutions, a subsidiary of EDF, will provide turbine island equipment for the first BWRX-300 small modular reactor project in Canada, marking a milestone for the industrialisation of SMRs in North America.
Framatome will supply nuclear fuel and technical services to ENEC, strengthening the United Arab Emirates’ energy supply chain for the Barakah nuclear plant.
French start-up Stellaria secures €23mn ($25.2mn) in funding to accelerate the design of its fast neutron nuclear reactor, with first fission expected in 2029 and commercial deployment targeted for 2035.
The Bulgarian National Audit Office report highlights persistent delays and contractual irregularities in the implementation of the national repository for low- and intermediate-level radioactive waste.
Bahrain has concluded a civil nuclear agreement with the United States and formalised a commitment of $17bn in public investments in the US market, further strengthening bilateral cooperation.
Kairos Power has installed the vessel for its third test prototype in Oak Ridge, aiming to validate manufacturing methods for its future Hermes reactor supported by the US Department of Energy.
London and Prague formalise a strategic partnership to develop the nuclear sector, focusing on small modular reactors and industrial cooperation on supply chains.
Experts have broadly approved France’s Cigéo deep nuclear waste repository project, highlighting technical uncertainties that demand stronger guarantees for long-term safety.
Uzbekistan advances its nuclear project by signing a protocol with Hungary for the supply and local assembly of dry cooling systems, expanding its industrial partnerships in the region.
Polskie Elektrownie Jądrowe is asking the European Commission to review its $49bn investment to build Poland’s first nuclear power plant, a step required under the Euratom Treaty before any construction permit can be issued.
The International Atomic Energy Agency mission completed on July 11 warns that the National Nuclear Safety Administration must hire staff to oversee a fleet of 59 reactors in operation and 32 more under construction.
Energoatom signed strategic agreements with Westinghouse and Holtec at the Ukraine Recovery Conference, aiming to establish nuclear fuel production and small modular reactor capabilities in the country.
Tehran agrees to reopen its nuclear facilities to the IAEA, aiming to resume negotiations with Washington, while Moscow pushes for a “zero enrichment” agreement without getting involved in supervision.
TerraPower has selected three new American suppliers for its advanced Natrium nuclear reactor, confirming progress on the project located in Kemmerer, Wyoming, intended to replace a retiring coal-fired power plant.
Energy Exploration Technologies acquires Daytona Lithium, an Australian subsidiary of Pantera Lithium, for AUD40mn ($27mn), bringing its strategic lithium basin footprint in Smackover, USA to nearly 50,000 acres.
The Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission has identified no major barriers to licensing the ARC-100 reactor, announces ARC Clean Technology.