popular articles

Ending Coal Use Through Carbon Credits?

A Rockefeller Foundation-led initiative aims to prematurely close coal-fired power plants in developing countries using carbon credits to reduce CO₂ emissions.

Please share:

In the vicinity of Manila, a coal-fired power plant hopes to become a model for developing countries striving to abandon this polluting fossil fuel. An alliance led by the Rockefeller Foundation, a philanthropic group, plans to help close this plant ten years earlier than scheduled, avoiding millions of tons of emissions by monetizing them as carbon credits.

“The idea is ‘pretty simple’,” explains Joseph Curtin, general director of Rockefeller’s energy and climate team, to AFP. “What if, instead of selling this high-carbon energy to the electrical grid, the coal owner could sell the avoided carbon emissions?”

Essentially, carbon credits allow a polluter to “offset” their own emissions by paying for “avoided” emissions elsewhere. They have been used to fund a large number of initiatives, from electric buses to protected forests, although it later emerged that many projects overestimated or incorrectly calculated the avoided emissions.

According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), coal is the leading source of human-induced carbon dioxide emissions. Some developed countries have gradually phased it out. However, it remains a cheap and reliable resource for developing economies facing growing energy demand.

Reluctance to Give Up Coal

Countries like Indonesia and South Africa have been offered billions of dollars to prematurely close coal-fired power plants. Without much success so far. “There isn’t a single coal-fired power plant, out of the 4,500 in emerging markets and developing countries, that has been closed and replaced with clean electricity,” regrets Mr. Curtin.

Because the problem is more complex than it seems. Not only is coal an affordable and reliable energy source, but it also represents millions of direct and indirect jobs. In Asia, power plants are often recent, meaning years of lost revenue in case of premature closure.

“There simply isn’t an economically viable exit strategy for the owners of these assets,” notes Mr. Curtin.

“Coal to Clean Credit Initiative” (CCCI)

This is where the “Coal to Clean Credit Initiative” (CCCI, “Initiative du charbon au crédit propre”) comes in. A program that aims to cover both the cost of closing coal-fired power plants and converting them to renewable energy production, notably wind and solar, by generating carbon credits.

With a pilot project: the South Luzon Thermal Energy Corporation (SLTEC) in the Philippines. This coal-fired plant is scheduled to operate until 2040. But under the CCCI, it would close ten years early, which would avoid 19 million tons of CO₂ emissions, according to the Rockefeller Foundation.

The plant would be replaced by a mix of renewable energy production and battery storage, and workers and the local community would be compensated.

Criticism and Challenges

However, the idea is subject to criticism, especially after the revelation of problems related to other carbon credit projects. A recurring issue: proving that emissions would not have been avoided anyway. This has hindered numerous forest protection programs, where promoters have failed to demonstrate that wooded areas were actually at risk of being cut down.

Elsewhere, trees meant to be protected were cut down while credits had already been sold to protect them. As renewable energies become cheaper, some argue that, carbon credits aside, market forces alone will eventually kill coal-fired power plants.

Future Perspectives

“It is difficult to know what forces are pushing for or against the gradual elimination of coal,” says Gilles Dufrasne from the think tank Carbon Market Watch. “These economic and political forces can change significantly,” he told AFP. According to him, carbon credits risk becoming a way to “reward investors who have placed their money in a highly polluting and doomed technology.”

Other analyses warn against the temptation for some countries to “double count” emission reductions related to coal plant closures, by including them in their national calculations even if these reductions have already been sold as carbon credits to offset emissions elsewhere. According to Mr. Curtin, the CCCI methodology is designed to avoid these pitfalls.

Only solvable coal-fired power plants, covered by long-term agreements and connected to the grid are eligible. Participating companies must permanently renounce coal and closures must be accompanied by a conversion to renewable energies and support for populations.

“And if someone has a better idea, let them share it with us,” assures Mr. Curtin. “Because we are constantly seeking new ways to address this problem.”

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

Subsea7 has been awarded a major contract by Equinor for Phase 2 of the Northern Lights project, involving the installation of a CO2 pipeline offshore Norway, with operations scheduled for 2026 and 2027.
Driven by investment in low-carbon technologies, the global decarbonisation market is expected to reach $4.7tn by 2033, according to Allied Market Research, with an average annual growth rate of 8.1%.
Driven by investment in low-carbon technologies, the global decarbonisation market is expected to reach $4.7tn by 2033, according to Allied Market Research, with an average annual growth rate of 8.1%.
Norwegian joint venture Northern Lights, backed by Equinor, Shell and TotalEnergies, will invest NOK7.5bn to expand its CO2 storage infrastructure following a new industrial contract signed in Sweden.
Norwegian joint venture Northern Lights, backed by Equinor, Shell and TotalEnergies, will invest NOK7.5bn to expand its CO2 storage infrastructure following a new industrial contract signed in Sweden.
Japanese conglomerate Mitsubishi Corporation has entered into a strategic partnership with Alt Carbon to scale up carbon dioxide removal across South Asia through an emerging mineral-based technology.
Japanese conglomerate Mitsubishi Corporation has entered into a strategic partnership with Alt Carbon to scale up carbon dioxide removal across South Asia through an emerging mineral-based technology.
British and European carbon markets extended gains, boosted by geopolitical tensions and prospects of aligning emissions trading systems.
Carbon Mapper and Planet Labs PBC will provide satellite data to California in support of a public programme targeting emission reductions in high-intensity sectors.
Carbon Mapper and Planet Labs PBC will provide satellite data to California in support of a public programme targeting emission reductions in high-intensity sectors.
A coalition of 30 companies and public organizations has launched an initiative to establish a standardized protocol for carbon credit data, aiming to improve transparency and accelerate the growth of carbon markets.
A coalition of 30 companies and public organizations has launched an initiative to establish a standardized protocol for carbon credit data, aiming to improve transparency and accelerate the growth of carbon markets.
Amid political uncertainty, CO2 capture players in the United States are shifting their messaging to safeguard the tax incentives crucial to their survival. The sector is now focusing on economic and strategic arguments to persuade the government.
Amid political uncertainty, CO2 capture players in the United States are shifting their messaging to safeguard the tax incentives crucial to their survival. The sector is now focusing on economic and strategic arguments to persuade the government.
8 Rivers Capital has entrusted Wood with the preliminary engineering and design phase of a carbon capture project in Wyoming. This project, carried out with PacifiCorp, aims to modernize an existing power plant by integrating a technology utilizing supercritical CO₂.
Recent movements in Europe’s carbon market have generated keen interest among investors. The price has experienced a notable decline, fueling questions about the forces that could trigger a potential rebound. -
Recent movements in Europe’s carbon market have generated keen interest among investors. The price has experienced a notable decline, fueling questions about the forces that could trigger a potential rebound. -
EU carbon permit prices declined at the end of February, influenced by market developments in gas and investor adjustments. Brussels' proposal concerning the CBAM has so far had little impact on market prices.
EU carbon permit prices declined at the end of February, influenced by market developments in gas and investor adjustments. Brussels' proposal concerning the CBAM has so far had little impact on market prices.
Baker Hughes and Frontier Infrastructure have announced a strategic partnership to accelerate the development of carbon storage and energy production projects in the United States, aimed at supporting the growing needs of data centres and industrial emitters.
Baker Hughes and Frontier Infrastructure have announced a strategic partnership to accelerate the development of carbon storage and energy production projects in the United States, aimed at supporting the growing needs of data centres and industrial emitters.
Perenco and its partners launch the first UK test for CO₂ injection into a depleted gas reservoir in the North Sea. This experimental phase aims to provide crucial data for the long-term geological storage of CO₂. ##
Captura, in collaboration with Equinor, has commissioned a new pilot facility in Kona, Hawaii, capable of capturing 1,000 tons of CO₂ per year. This milestone marks a key step toward the large-scale deployment of Direct Ocean Capture (DOC) technology.
Captura, in collaboration with Equinor, has commissioned a new pilot facility in Kona, Hawaii, capable of capturing 1,000 tons of CO₂ per year. This milestone marks a key step toward the large-scale deployment of Direct Ocean Capture (DOC) technology.
Lydian takes a strategic step forward by demonstrating a technology that uses captured CO2 and renewable electricity to produce sustainable aviation fuel, addressing both civil market demands and critical military needs.
Lydian takes a strategic step forward by demonstrating a technology that uses captured CO2 and renewable electricity to produce sustainable aviation fuel, addressing both civil market demands and critical military needs.
A study published in Scientific Reports reveals new allometric equations dedicated to Colophospermum mopane. These models aim to better manage biomass and encourage decarbonization practices for economic players in the forestry sector.
A study published in Scientific Reports reveals new allometric equations dedicated to Colophospermum mopane. These models aim to better manage biomass and encourage decarbonization practices for economic players in the forestry sector.
Carbon dioxide removal strategies are expanding in India with new initiatives and a potential rise in demand in 2025. This article explores the major factors driving this trend and the technological perspectives.
A Norwegian shipowner has equipped an ethylene carrier with an onboard CO2 capture and storage system. The initiative could reduce its greenhouse gas emissions by 70%.
A Norwegian shipowner has equipped an ethylene carrier with an onboard CO2 capture and storage system. The initiative could reduce its greenhouse gas emissions by 70%.
Gigablue and SkiesFifty collaborate to capture 200,000 tons of CO₂ through innovative marine solutions, strengthening aviation's net-zero ambitions.
Gigablue and SkiesFifty collaborate to capture 200,000 tons of CO₂ through innovative marine solutions, strengthening aviation's net-zero ambitions.
The Gulf Coast of the United States is developing carbon capture projects to decarbonize its heavy industries, but regulatory and financial challenges are slowing implementation.
The Gulf Coast of the United States is developing carbon capture projects to decarbonize its heavy industries, but regulatory and financial challenges are slowing implementation.
The U.S. Department of Energy is funding a 200 million USD project led by Technip Energies and LanzaTech to convert captured CO2 into ethanol and ethylene, reducing the carbon footprint of the chemical industry.
In 2025, China plans to expand its carbon market by integrating steel, cement, and aluminum sectors while introducing new methodologies for carbon credits. A strategic overhaul will also aim to better address international requirements.
In 2025, China plans to expand its carbon market by integrating steel, cement, and aluminum sectors while introducing new methodologies for carbon credits. A strategic overhaul will also aim to better address international requirements.
Technip Energies, in partnership with GE Vernova and Balfour Beatty, is building the UK’s first gas-fired plant equipped with a carbon capture system, marking a significant step in reducing industrial emissions.
Technip Energies, in partnership with GE Vernova and Balfour Beatty, is building the UK’s first gas-fired plant equipped with a carbon capture system, marking a significant step in reducing industrial emissions.
Maritime transport is essential to cross-border carbon capture and storage initiatives in Asia-Pacific, with projected annual volumes reaching 100 million tons by 2050.
Maritime transport is essential to cross-border carbon capture and storage initiatives in Asia-Pacific, with projected annual volumes reaching 100 million tons by 2050.

Advertising