popular articles

Dutch court rejects climate NGOs’ appeal against Shell

The Hague's Court of Appeal overturned a historic decision obliging Shell to reduce its CO2 emissions, rejecting the environmental NGOs' appeal, which denounced the multinational's inaction on climate.

Please share:

The Hague’s Court of Appeal ruled in favor of Shell this Tuesday, dismissing claims by climate defense groups such as Milieudefensie and Greenpeace, which sought to compel the oil giant to adopt stricter CO2 reduction targets. This decision reverses the judgment rendered in 2021 by a Dutch court, which had ordered Shell to reduce its net CO2 emissions by at least 45% by 2030 from 2019 levels.

Reasons behind the court’s decision

Judge Carla Joustra stated that the arguments presented by the NGOs were insufficient to justify such an obligation on Shell. She clarified that the matter was more of a political decision to be taken by governments rather than a legal constraint imposed on a private company. Shell, for its part, argued that emission reduction goals require coordination at national and international levels, rather than individual actions imposed by the courts. Shell’s CEO, Wael Sawan, welcomed the decision, asserting that it supports the company’s strategic approach toward a balanced energy transition. He reiterated Shell’s commitment to achieving net-zero emissions by 2050 while maintaining an effort to halve emissions from its direct operations by 2030.

Reactions from NGOs and climate activists

Milieudefensie’s director, the Dutch branch of Friends of the Earth, expressed disappointment at this judicial setback. He stated that although the outcome is a blow, it does not erase the progress made in raising public awareness of large corporations’ responsibility in the fight against climate change. According to him, the lawsuit against Shell has highlighted the environmental impact of large multinationals, thus stimulating the debate on their role in carbon reduction. Despite this decision, Milieudefensie and other NGOs are now considering taking the case to the Supreme Court. However, the Supreme Court will not review the facts but will instead focus on the procedural aspects of the judgment.

A precedent in the fight against climate change

This lawsuit, known as “the people against Shell,” was initially launched in 2019, supported by more than 17,000 Dutch citizens. The case sought to force Shell to align with the 2015 Paris Agreement goals, which commit nations to limit global warming to 2°C, or even 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels. In 2021, the initial judgment by The Hague’s court marked a historic turning point by imposing precise emission reduction obligations on a multinational, according to the Paris Agreement criteria. This victory was widely hailed by environmental activists, who considered it a precedent in efforts to hold large companies accountable for climate issues.

Shell and BP’s climate target adjustments

In recent months, Shell and other energy companies, notably BP, have revised some of their climate targets, placing increased emphasis on oil and gas activities to boost profits. This strategic shift has angered environmental activists, who believe it moves these companies further from their environmental commitments. The reduction in climate ambitions of these multinationals contrasts with the efforts of many countries and organizations to strengthen greenhouse gas reduction targets.

For now, the Dutch court of appeal’s decision may hinder attempts to regulate multinational corporations judicially on climate matters, but the debate on their climate responsibility remains active and continues to fuel international discussions.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

Brazilian oil major Petrobras reported a $6bn net profit in Q1 2025, driven by higher production volumes and a stronger real against the US dollar.
Namibia plans to finalise agreements with TotalEnergies for the Venus oil field and with BWEnergy for the Kudu gas field by the end of 2026, according to the country’s petroleum commissioner.
Namibia plans to finalise agreements with TotalEnergies for the Venus oil field and with BWEnergy for the Kudu gas field by the end of 2026, according to the country’s petroleum commissioner.
The Trump administration has announced new sanctions targeting Iran's oil export network to China amid ongoing nuclear talks between Washington and Tehran.
The Trump administration has announced new sanctions targeting Iran's oil export network to China amid ongoing nuclear talks between Washington and Tehran.
Japanese refiners, dependent on Gulf crude for 96.6% of imports, are struggling to diversify supply sources as increased OPEC+ output makes Persian Gulf barrels more competitive compared to US crude.
Japanese refiners, dependent on Gulf crude for 96.6% of imports, are struggling to diversify supply sources as increased OPEC+ output makes Persian Gulf barrels more competitive compared to US crude.
Esso’s Gravenchon site restarts operations following a planned shutdown involving 1,000 workers and over 750,000 labour hours.
Deputy Prime Minister Alexander Novak says Russian oil production could reach a sustained level of 10.8 million barrels per day, supported by rising global demand and internal fiscal adjustments.
Deputy Prime Minister Alexander Novak says Russian oil production could reach a sustained level of 10.8 million barrels per day, supported by rising global demand and internal fiscal adjustments.
Oil prices climbed following a joint decision by Washington and Beijing to temporarily suspend tariffs, easing pressure on global demand.
Oil prices climbed following a joint decision by Washington and Beijing to temporarily suspend tariffs, easing pressure on global demand.
Shell announced a delay in bringing two new wells online at the Perdido offshore field, temporarily lowering production targets in the Gulf of Mexico.
Shell announced a delay in bringing two new wells online at the Perdido offshore field, temporarily lowering production targets in the Gulf of Mexico.
Lower sales revenues and rising operational costs impacted Aramco’s results, while the company remains central to Saudi Arabia’s economic strategy.
Oil prices climbed on Friday, supported by the signing of a trade agreement between the United States and the United Kingdom, reviving expectations of easing global tensions.
Oil prices climbed on Friday, supported by the signing of a trade agreement between the United States and the United Kingdom, reviving expectations of easing global tensions.
California approved only three new drilling permits in Q1 2025, but Kern County and two CO₂ pipeline bills may reverse that trend.
California approved only three new drilling permits in Q1 2025, but Kern County and two CO₂ pipeline bills may reverse that trend.
US oil operators will face moderate drilling cost increases in 2025, driven by tariffs, despite price drops in several key service segments.
US oil operators will face moderate drilling cost increases in 2025, driven by tariffs, despite price drops in several key service segments.
BluEnergies Ltd. has announced the immediate appointment of Craig Steinke as Chief Executive Officer, succeeding James Deckelman, who is stepping down for personal reasons.
The increase in tariffs between the United States and China is radically reshaping China's petrochemical supply flows, threatening to raise costs and intensify supply challenges in an already strained strategic sector.
The increase in tariffs between the United States and China is radically reshaping China's petrochemical supply flows, threatening to raise costs and intensify supply challenges in an already strained strategic sector.
The United States imposes sanctions on several Chinese entities involved in purchasing and transporting Iranian oil, disrupting a petroleum supply chain worth several hundred million dollars.
The United States imposes sanctions on several Chinese entities involved in purchasing and transporting Iranian oil, disrupting a petroleum supply chain worth several hundred million dollars.
Brent and WTI prices surged after the announcement of a trade deal between the United States and the United Kingdom, raising expectations of a rebound in global crude demand.
Brent and WTI prices surged after the announcement of a trade deal between the United States and the United Kingdom, raising expectations of a rebound in global crude demand.
US commercial crude oil reserves dropped more than expected in early May, supported by increased refinery activity, according to the latest data from the Energy Information Administration.
Oil prices are trending downward under the combined pressure of increased output from Opec+ members and the potential for a nuclear deal between Iran and the United States.
Oil prices are trending downward under the combined pressure of increased output from Opec+ members and the potential for a nuclear deal between Iran and the United States.
The Venezuelan government confirmed it will continue operating Chevron’s oil fields after the US-imposed withdrawal of the American company.
The Venezuelan government confirmed it will continue operating Chevron’s oil fields after the US-imposed withdrawal of the American company.
BP rises on the London Stock Exchange amid acquisition rumours by Shell, which may wait for a further drop in oil prices before taking action.
BP rises on the London Stock Exchange amid acquisition rumours by Shell, which may wait for a further drop in oil prices before taking action.
Crude prices gained momentum after a drop triggered by OPEC+, supported by strong gasoline demand in the United States ahead of the summer season.
Petrobras has awarded Subsea7 a large-scale contract for the development of the Búzios 11 field, located in the pre-salt Santos basin offshore Brazil.
Petrobras has awarded Subsea7 a large-scale contract for the development of the Búzios 11 field, located in the pre-salt Santos basin offshore Brazil.
Norway’s Equinor sells its majority stake in Brazil’s offshore Peregrino field to PRIO for $3.5 billion, shifting focus to Bacalhau and the Raia gas project.
Norway’s Equinor sells its majority stake in Brazil’s offshore Peregrino field to PRIO for $3.5 billion, shifting focus to Bacalhau and the Raia gas project.
Shell has completed the acquisition of additional shares in the Ursa oil platform and its associated pipeline, raising its stake to over 61% in both assets.
Shell has completed the acquisition of additional shares in the Ursa oil platform and its associated pipeline, raising its stake to over 61% in both assets.

Advertising