popular articles

Breakup of Gas Transit via Ukraine: Stakes and Consequences for Europe and Russia

The expiration of the gas transit agreement between Russia and Ukraine highlights the energy and economic challenges for the European Union, Russia, and Ukraine, exacerbating Europe's dependence on Russian gas and geopolitical tensions.

Please share:

The announcement by Alexander Novak, Russian Deputy Prime Minister, regarding gas transit via Ukraine reveals several strategic issues for Russia, Ukraine, and the European Union (EU). At the end of 2024, the current gas transit agreement between Russia and Ukraine is set to expire. While Russia is open to continuing supplies, Ukraine has repeatedly stated that it will not renew this agreement. This situation places the EU in a delicate position, as some European countries continue to rely on Russian gas flows for their energy consumption.

Despite the drastic reduction in EU imports of Russian gas since the beginning of the war in Ukraine, countries like Slovakia, Austria, and Hungary still depend on these supplies. Slovakia, in particular, is in a vulnerable position as it lacks solid alternatives. It might attempt to establish a reverse flow from Austria or import via liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminals in Germany, but this would incur additional costs.

Economic Impact for Ukraine

For Ukraine, the end of gas transit could have significant economic consequences. Currently, Kyiv generates approximately 714 million euros in annual revenue from Russian gas transit, which is below the initially projected 1.25 billion euros. However, maintaining this infrastructure is costly. The Ukrainian pipeline network, designed to transport large quantities of gas, requires high maintenance costs, estimated at around 892 million euros per year, to remain operational. If Russian transit stops, Ukraine will need to find alternative means to finance these costs while ensuring that the pipelines continue to meet domestic needs.

Repercussions for Russia and the EU

Russia could suffer a loss of 7 to 8 billion dollars in annual revenue, representing about 15% of Gazprom’s total revenue. These losses could not be offset by alternative markets for several years. The construction of the “Power of Siberia 2” pipeline to China is not planned before 2030, and an LNG terminal project on the Baltic Sea would not be operational until 2026-2027. Additionally, the end of this transit could trigger damage claims from European customers, some contracts of which extend until 2040.

For the EU, the loss of 15 billion cubic meters of gas transported via Ukraine each year would be a shock for some Central and Eastern European countries. Even though the EU’s overall dependence on Russian gas has been reduced, Russia’s share in total gas imports remains significant, accounting for about 15% in the second quarter of 2024, just behind the 19% from the United States. Countries like Hungary and Slovakia, which do not have access to the sea for importing LNG, would be forced to find other sources at a much higher cost.

Strategies and Perspectives

To attempt to circumvent the potential blockage, one of the options being explored is for European companies to sign transport contracts directly with Ukraine, rather than through bilateral contracts with Gazprom. This would allow Ukraine to continue to collect transit fees while aligning with European needs. However, any definitive cutoff of gas flow through Ukraine would significantly increase costs for EU countries that are already using reverse flow mechanisms to import gas at lower costs.

The situation remains complex and evolving. A definitive rupture of transit via Ukraine would harm not only Russian gas revenues but also the energy security of several European countries. Russia might turn more towards Asia, but these markets will not compensate for European losses in the near future. On its side, Ukraine could benefit from a reorganized transit system, but this would require significant investments to adapt its infrastructure. For Europe, finding alternative solutions remains limited by geographical constraints and high logistical costs.

The final decision will depend on negotiations between the EU, Ukraine, and Russia, as discussions have already been initiated to explore options via other routes, notably through Turkey and Azerbaijan.

Register free of charge for uninterrupted access.

Publicite

Recently published in

Wood Mackenzie warns of a potential gas supply deficit in Indonesia, due to slow development of untapped resources and a lack of attractive regulatory framework.
Mubadala Energy will supply natural gas to two Pupuk Indonesia plants starting in late 2028, when production begins at the South Andaman block, according to statements made at an industry forum in Jakarta.
Mubadala Energy will supply natural gas to two Pupuk Indonesia plants starting in late 2028, when production begins at the South Andaman block, according to statements made at an industry forum in Jakarta.
QatarEnergy is set to begin liquefied natural gas production in the US by the end of 2025 and expand its North Field East project in Qatar starting mid-2026.
QatarEnergy is set to begin liquefied natural gas production in the US by the end of 2025 and expand its North Field East project in Qatar starting mid-2026.
TotalEnergies has signed a 20-year contract to purchase 2 million tonnes per annum (Mtpa) of LNG from Ksi Lisims LNG, a liquefaction project located in British Columbia, Canada.
TotalEnergies has signed a 20-year contract to purchase 2 million tonnes per annum (Mtpa) of LNG from Ksi Lisims LNG, a liquefaction project located in British Columbia, Canada.
Shell shareholders approved 21 out of 22 resolutions at the Annual General Meeting, rejecting a motion related to liquefied natural gas activities despite strong overall support for the group’s strategy.
An Australian tribunal has approved Santos' $2.3 billion Narrabri gas project despite objections from Indigenous communities and environmental concerns, citing major public benefits for gas supply.
An Australian tribunal has approved Santos' $2.3 billion Narrabri gas project despite objections from Indigenous communities and environmental concerns, citing major public benefits for gas supply.
Kurdistan signs oil and gas development agreements with HKN Energy and Western Zagros worth $110bn over the projects’ lifespan.
Kurdistan signs oil and gas development agreements with HKN Energy and Western Zagros worth $110bn over the projects’ lifespan.
Indonesian state-owned oil company PT Pertamina has signed ten gas sales agreements with domestic firms, including gas distributor PGN and electricity provider PLN.
Indonesian state-owned oil company PT Pertamina has signed ten gas sales agreements with domestic firms, including gas distributor PGN and electricity provider PLN.
Physical and derivatives trading of liquefied natural gas in Asia reached unprecedented levels during the June pricing period, with a significant increase in bids and transactions amid the shoulder season.
Mexico could eliminate imports of 384 billion cubic feet of gas per year by reaching 45% clean electricity by 2030, according to Ember.
Mexico could eliminate imports of 384 billion cubic feet of gas per year by reaching 45% clean electricity by 2030, according to Ember.
Energean transfers its offshore stakes in Morocco to Chariot just one year after entering the market, following below-expectation outcomes from the Anchois-3 gas well.
Energean transfers its offshore stakes in Morocco to Chariot just one year after entering the market, following below-expectation outcomes from the Anchois-3 gas well.
Ankara announces the discovery of a new Black Sea gas reserve worth $30bn as part of its strategy to boost public investment in the energy sector.
Ankara announces the discovery of a new Black Sea gas reserve worth $30bn as part of its strategy to boost public investment in the energy sector.
Two new oil and gas sites in the Natuna Sea are expected to produce 20,000 barrels of oil and 60 million cubic metres of gas per day.
A CAD715mn ($524mn) partnership enables First Nations to co-own the Westcoast system, backed by a federal loan guarantee of CAD400mn ($293mn).
A CAD715mn ($524mn) partnership enables First Nations to co-own the Westcoast system, backed by a federal loan guarantee of CAD400mn ($293mn).
Tallgrass Energy announces plans for a pipeline directly connecting the Permian Basin to the Rockies Express network, scheduled to start operations in late 2028 after securing initial commercial agreements with key shippers.
Tallgrass Energy announces plans for a pipeline directly connecting the Permian Basin to the Rockies Express network, scheduled to start operations in late 2028 after securing initial commercial agreements with key shippers.
Woodside Energy has announced a collaboration agreement with Saudi Aramco for a potential stake in its $17.5bn liquefied natural gas project in Louisiana, scheduled to begin production in 2029.
Woodside Energy has announced a collaboration agreement with Saudi Aramco for a potential stake in its $17.5bn liquefied natural gas project in Louisiana, scheduled to begin production in 2029.
Sinopec announced a new vertical depth record with its Tiebei 1HF well, reaching 5,300 metres and producing over 314,000 cubic metres of gas per day in the Sichuan Basin.
McDermott has completed the offshore installation of the Scarborough floating platform for Woodside Energy, marking a key step in the preparatory maintenance phase of the gas project in Western Australia.
McDermott has completed the offshore installation of the Scarborough floating platform for Woodside Energy, marking a key step in the preparatory maintenance phase of the gas project in Western Australia.
The fund managed by ArcLight Capital Partners has acquired 25% of Natural Gas Pipeline Company of America, bringing its total stake to 62.5% alongside Kinder Morgan.
The fund managed by ArcLight Capital Partners has acquired 25% of Natural Gas Pipeline Company of America, bringing its total stake to 62.5% alongside Kinder Morgan.
The Ontario Securities Commission has imposed a trading suspension on LNG Energy Group due to the non-filing of its annual financial statements for fiscal year 2024.
The Ontario Securities Commission has imposed a trading suspension on LNG Energy Group due to the non-filing of its annual financial statements for fiscal year 2024.
Diaco Aviki succeeds Thomas King at the helm of Woodway Energy Infrastructure amid expansion of its natural gas infrastructure in Texas.
Brussels announces a full exit from Russian gas by the end of 2027, despite a remaining 9% dependency and pressure on the global liquefied natural gas market.
Brussels announces a full exit from Russian gas by the end of 2027, despite a remaining 9% dependency and pressure on the global liquefied natural gas market.
US-based SiEnergy strengthens its footprint around Houston by acquiring Hughes Gas Resources, an EPCOR subsidiary, for $60mn, expanding its natural gas asset portfolio.
US-based SiEnergy strengthens its footprint around Houston by acquiring Hughes Gas Resources, an EPCOR subsidiary, for $60mn, expanding its natural gas asset portfolio.
US-based Commonwealth LNG has secured a 20-year supply agreement for 1 million tonnes of LNG per year with a major Asian company, reinforcing the development of its Louisiana terminal.
US-based Commonwealth LNG has secured a 20-year supply agreement for 1 million tonnes of LNG per year with a major Asian company, reinforcing the development of its Louisiana terminal.

Advertising