Turkey dreams of an improbable gas pipeline with Israel


Turkey is dreaming of a gas pipeline linking it to Israel to export Israeli gas to Europe and hopes to revive the project thanks to the war between Ukraine and Russia, which is weighing on energy supplies. But such a project, with its complex and costly logistics, seems difficult to achieve in the eyes of the experts. Israeli President Isaac Herzog’s visit in March to Ankara and Istanbul to renew ties with his counterpart Recep Tayyip Erdogan opened a new era in their relations, according to both officials, after a decade of tensions.

Turkey wants to cooperate with Israel

The Turkish head of state said he was “ready to cooperate with Israel on energy and energy security”, with the idea of transporting Israeli gas to Europe via Turkey, while the war in Ukraine threatens Europe with shortages. “Turkey has the experience and capacity to implement these projects,” said the head of state. Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu will visit Israel on Wednesday. Energy Minister Fatih Dönmez will probably accompany him. But the Turkish authorities have not yet confirmed this.

At this stage, however, Turkish enthusiasm is not shared on the Israeli side. “The prevailing feeling is that in matters of energy, countries must trust each other. This is not what characterizes the dynamic between the two countries,” notes Gabi Mitchell, an associate at the Mitvim Institute who specializes in Israel’s regional politics. “For some, Erdogan is not a reliable partner,” he adds. In 2009, he walked out of a Davos roundtable after a tense exchange with then-Israeli President Shimon Peres over the Palestinians. Then in 2010, ten civilians were killed by an Israeli raid on a Turkish ship that was attempting to deliver aid to the Gaza Strip, which is under Israeli blockade.

“Complicated and expensive.”

But Erdogan recently silenced his critics and expressed only “sadness” at the clashes on the Mosque Esplanade in April. In 2016, the two countries had agreed to study the feasibility of a subsea gas pipeline to Turkey and Europe. Since then the project has not progressed. “I never thought the project was feasible,” says Aaron Stein, director of the Middle East program at the Foreign Policy Research Institute in Washington. “The idea comes up every time there is a rapprochement between the two countries, but the logistics of turning the dream into reality are complicated and costly,” he adds.

An undersea gas pipeline from Israel to Turkey would cost $1.5 billion, according to some studies. The Turkish option reappeared after the United States abandoned the EastMed gas pipeline project in the eastern Mediterranean aimed at transporting Israeli gas to Europe via Cyprus and Greece, excluding Turkey. Despite the difficulties, Ankara believes that the new pipeline plan is more feasible. “It is difficult but reasonable and, above all, feasible in comparison to EastMed,” says a Turkish official, speaking on condition of anonymity.

New contracts needed

Turkey is closely dependent on Russia for its energy supplies and is seeking to diversify sources. “A gas pipeline through southern Turkey makes sense,” says Necdet Pamir, an energy expert at Cyprus International University. Turkey consumed 48 billion cubic meters of gas in 2020 and 60 billion in 2021 and is expected to reach 62 to 63 billion this year, he added. Last year, 45% of the gas consumed in Turkey came from Russia, the rest from Iran and Azerbaijan, supplemented by liquefied natural gas (LNG) from Qatar, Nigeria, Algeria and the US.

“We need alternative sources of supply,” Pamir insists. However, the gas pipeline project with Israel would cross the eastern Mediterranean where Turkey, Cyprus and Greece, members of the European Union, are often at odds. For this reason, “the project does not interest Israel because it could harm its relations” with these two countries and the EU, says Gabi Mitchell. At this stage, onshore LNG terminals seem more realistic, “financially they make more sense”, says Mr Stein. “And politically, it’s easier.”

Articles qui pourraient vous intéresser


Europe considers classifying Lithium as toxic

In 2021, the French government put forward proposals to classify lithium carbonate, lithium hydroxide and lithium chloride as Category 1A reproductive toxicants. Lithium as a toxic substance, a counterproductive measure? Lithium is used in particular for the manufacture of batteries. At the end of 2021, the European Agency's risk assessment committee accepted the French proposals. The first bill reclassifying lithium compounds is expected to be released between October and December. A category 1A classification makes a substance eligible as a substance of very high concern. This leads to a restriction of its use by the EU Chemical Strategy for Sustainable Development. Several industry players opposed the bill. Roland Chavasse, Secretary General of the International Lithium Association explains: "The risk is that if lithium components are wrongly reclassified in this category, it would introduce uncertainty in planning the long-term commercial viability of the investments around it." The EU aims to become self-sufficient in the production of lithium-ion batteries for electric vehicles by 2025. It is also targeting a domestic lithium production of 80% in the next five years. It also seeks to achieve 35% lithium recycling by 2029. Thus, industry believes that such a proposal would be counterproductive, and would hamper...

éoliennes dans l'alberta

BluEarth builds a wind farm in Alberta

BluEarth Renewable Inc. has launched the construction of its 145 MW Hand Hills wind project in Canada. The project aims to supply the region with energy as well as capital. BluEarth builds its first Canadian project BluEarth Renewable Inc is a Canadian company specialized in renewable energy. On June 27, the company launched the construction of the 145 MW Hand Hills wind farm. The project, located northeast of Drumheller, Alberta, will produce enough clean, renewable energy to power approximately 68,000 homes per year. BluEarth estimates that it should go into commercial service in early 2023. Shell Energy North America will purchase electricity and associated emissions offsets from 100 MW of project capacity. The company's goal is to become a net zero emissions energy company by 2050. BluEarth has developed the project since its acquisition in 2012 and will be the long-term operator of the facility. An important project for the region The Hand Hills wind project will also provide indirect revenues to the local municipality in the form of local services and supplies. It will also contribute to significant and stable property tax revenues over the long term. The project will inject more than $250 million in capital investment into...

D'ici huit ans, Axpo vise une capacité de 10 GW dans les parcs solaires et 3 GW pour les sites d'énergie éolienne (archives).

Axpo develops two wind farms in Romania

Today, Axpo is the largest producer of renewable energy in Switzerland and one of the leading companies in Europe. The company announces the expansion of its wind power business, which currently has 3.5 GW of installed capacity worldwide. Also, it plans to develop two wind farms with a combined total of 38 wind turbines in Romania. Axpo develops two new wind farms Axpo has just announced the development of two new wind farms in Romania. While the project is currently in the planning phase, construction is expected to begin in late 2023. The two parks will be located approximately 100 km northeast and 200 km east of Bucharest respectively. Axpo estimates the annual production of the plants at 750 GWh of electricity. This represents the electricity consumption of about 375,000 Romanian households. Axpo will work closely with local partner Aquarius Energy Developments to complete the project. Moreover, the development of wind energy in Romania will create many jobs. The entire project development sector will benefit, from land acquisition to operations management. A desire to develop new markets Axpo is pursuing a niche strategy in new markets. In other words, this represents markets that are not the focus of large wind...

Union Européenne

New European Laws for Renewable Energy

The European ministers are in the middle of a discussion on a set of laws. These concern climate ambitions and the energy question. Numerous laws forcing member countries to reduce their greenhouse gas emissions have already been approved. However, there are several proposals that continue to be debated. Russian dependence, a new issue to be taken into account Among the measures taken, the European Union wants to reduce its demand for gas. This would allow member countries to reduce their dependence on Russian gas. This independence from Russia is a priority. The European Commission will soon present a new plan to lower imports from Russia in a coordinated manner. But Energy Commissioner Kadri Simson insists that consumer protection remains the priority. This will require effective means to reduce demand. Ministers are still seeking agreement on emission reduction legislation. These would force the Union to cut its carbon emissions to below 55% of 1990 levels. In the past, such laws were less debated. With the current supply shortage, such reforms are becoming more difficult. Indeed, several member states fear that environmental efforts will slow down due to the current state of the markets. Promoting renewable energy and reducing consumption, the objective...

Dernières Nouvelles